Decatur Magazine
PO Box 498, Decatur 62525
Current issue: COMMUNITY SPIRIT Decatur Magazine exists to remind us what it means to take pride in one’s hometown by telling local stories about the people and places that make t...
American Dread | True crime from the dark side of the American Heartland.
Forgotten murders. Missing persons. Cold cases.
Stories that deserve to be remembered.
Hosted by Adam White | American Hauntings Podcast Network | New episodes every other Wed.. American Dread — True stories of tragedy and terror from the dark side of the American Heartland. Hosted by Adam White. #TrueCrime #Podcast
11/13/2026
A huge thank you to everyone who has recently joined us here on Facebook, and to those who have been following and supporting American Dread along the way.
For those who may be new, American Dread is a true crime podcast dedicated to telling the lesser-known stories from across the American Heartland — and occasionally just beyond it. New episodes are released every other Wednesday and focus on murders, missing persons, cold cases, and crimes that often never received the attention they deserved.
While many true crime shows focus on the cases everyone already knows, our goal is a little different. We want to tell the stories that have been overlooked, forgotten, or simply aren't talked about enough. These victims and their families matter just as much, and we believe their stories deserve to be heard.
You can visit AmericanDread.com for our latest episodes, links to listen on your favorite podcast platform, contact emails, reviews, ways to support the show, confidential case tip forms, and more.
Please continue to like, share, and comment on our posts. Every interaction helps American Dread grow and, more importantly, helps put these stories in front of more people.
Thank you for being here and for supporting what we're building.
Adam
Host of American Dread
American Dread True stories of tragedy and terror.
11/12/2026
Karen Snider was only 18 years old when her life ended inside her Calumet City home. She was a young wife, a new mother, and at an age when most people are still trying to decide what adulthood is supposed to look like. Just a little more than two months earlier, Karen and her husband, Paul, had welcomed a baby girl named Paula.
On the morning of November 12, 1966, Karen spoke on the telephone with a friend. They talked about their babies, an upcoming birthday, and the kind of ordinary things that would have seemed completely forgettable at the time. There was no reason for anyone to believe that conversation would later become one of the final known moments of Karen’s life.
Later that day, Paul went to work at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad, leaving Karen and their infant daughter at home. Sometime while he was gone, someone came inside.
What happened next was incredibly violent. Karen was attacked and stabbed more than 120 times, suffering wounds to her neck, chest, hands and other parts of her body. The injuries to her hands showed that she had tried to defend herself. Only a short distance away, her two-and-a-half-month-old daughter remained in her bassinet, completely unharmed.
Karen was discovered later that night, and investigators immediately began looking at the people who knew her and her husband. One of those people was James Barbier, a coworker of Paul’s who had also spent time around the Snider family. Police reportedly noticed injuries on Barbier when he attended Karen’s funeral, and he quickly became a person of interest.
The problem was that investigators in 1966 were working with a very different set of tools. DNA testing did not exist, and although evidence had been collected from Karen and the crime scene, police could not use it in the way investigators can today. Barbier was never charged, the case eventually went cold, and Karen’s daughter grew up without knowing who had killed her mother.
For decades, the evidence sat quietly while technology changed around it.
Then, in 2022, Calumet City police received a phone call from a man who had heard members of his family talk about Karen’s murder for years. That call helped bring new attention to the old case, and detectives began reviewing what evidence still remained.
Among the items that had survived were pieces of Karen’s clothing.
Modern testing found DNA evidence that prosecutors later said pointed to James Barbier, the same man investigators had looked at nearly 60 years earlier. In 2024, Barbier was arrested in Missouri and charged with Karen’s murder.
His trial finally took place in November 2026.
Prosecutors argued that Barbier knew Karen, knew her husband was away at work, and left behind blood evidence that linked him to the crime. His defense challenged the reliability of evidence that had been stored for decades and pointed out that much of the original investigation had been lost to time, including witnesses who were no longer alive.
Nearly 60 years after Karen’s death, a jury was finally asked to decide what happened inside that Calumet City home.
On November 9, 2026, they returned a guilty verdict.
Three days later marked the 60th anniversary of Karen Snider’s murder.
Karen never got the chance to watch her daughter grow up, and her daughter spent almost her entire life without an answer to one of the most painful questions imaginable. Yet evidence collected in 1966 survived long enough for science to finally catch up with it.
Sometimes a cold case is not waiting for a confession or a new witness.
Sometimes it is simply waiting for the right technology.
How many other decades-old cases do you think are sitting in evidence rooms right now, waiting for one new test to finally tell their story?
— American Dread
11/11/2026
More than 160 years ago, a young woman disappeared while walking through the countryside south of Pontiac, Illinois. Her name was Mary Murphy.
Mary was an Irish immigrant's daughter and was described in newspaper reports as being only about 16 years old. She had been working as a domestic in Pontiac and had returned to her father's home near Rooks Creek to collect clothing before heading back into town.
But Mary never made it. For roughly 18 days, there was no sign of her. Then, on November 11, 1858, her body was discovered near the railroad tracks a few miles south of Pontiac.
The condition of Mary's remains left little doubt that something terrible had happened. The coroner's jury reported injuries to her head and evidence suggesting she may have been strangled. Contemporary newspaper coverage reported that her body appeared to have been dragged onto the prairie and abandoned.
Someone had killed Mary Murphy and left her there.
The investigation eventually focused on a Black man known under several names, including Wiley J. Morris. He had reportedly been seen traveling along the railroad not far behind Mary around the time she disappeared.
The evidence against him was circumstantial. Morris maintained that he was innocent.
His defense argued that simply being seen in the area did not make him Mary's killer. Historical accounts also acknowledge something that cannot be ignored when looking back at the case today: Morris was a Black man facing a murder accusation in Illinois during the years immediately before the Civil War, and racial prejudice surrounded the proceedings.
His first trial did not end with a conviction. The case was eventually moved to Kankakee County, where Morris was tried again. This time, he was convicted of murder and sentenced to death.
In 1861, Wiley Morris was hanged.
According to a later Livingston County history, he continued proclaiming his innocence until the end. But Mary's story did not end at the gallows.
Years later, reports began appearing that other men had admitted knowledge of—or responsibility for—Mary Murphy's murder. One historical account describes a dying outlaw confessing that members of his gang had encountered Mary near Pontiac, held her captive and ultimately murdered her before leaving the area.
Another account published in 1877 reported that men imprisoned in Ohio had confessed to Mary's murder and questioned whether Illinois had executed an innocent man.
More than a century later, separating every verified fact from the stories and confessions that followed is difficult. Some later accounts even disagree on details of what supposedly happened to Mary.
But one fact remains. A teenage girl left her father's home in rural Livingston County in the fall of 1858. She never made it back to Pontiac.
Eighteen days later, Mary Murphy was found dead beside the railroad. A man was eventually hanged for killing her.
And years afterward, evidence surfaced suggesting that the man Illinois executed may not have been Mary's killer at all.
168 years ago today, Mary Murphy was found outside Pontiac, Illinois.
Her story became one of the earliest and most troubling murder cases in Livingston County history—and one that still leaves uncomfortable questions about who really killed Mary Murphy and whether another innocent life was taken in the search for justice.
Follow American Dread for more forgotten crimes, cold cases and stories buried in the history of the Midwest.
11/10/2026
In the early morning hours of November 10, 1962, 43-year-old Edward J. Kriz finished another night of work at George’s Buffet Tavern in Iowa City, Iowa. Edward, a World War II Army veteran, owned the tavern with his wife, Bernice. After closing, the couple and one of their bartenders followed a familiar routine and walked a short distance to the Hamburg Inn No. 2 for coffee and something to eat.
Around 2:00 a.m., Edward and Bernice left through the back door and stepped into the alley. Waiting nearby was a young man wearing a Halloween mask who investigators believed intended to rob the restaurant.
Suddenly, a gunshot rang out.
Edward was hit but managed to move toward the masked man. During the struggle, two more shots were fired before Edward collapsed. The gunman ran into the darkness, leaving Edward mortally wounded. He was taken to the hospital but died only minutes later.
Police quickly began searching for the masked killer. Near the scene, an officer recovered a button believed to have been torn from the attacker’s coat during the struggle. Three .45-caliber shell casings were also recovered.
Only days later, police arrested 18-year-old Robert Joseph Schneider. Investigators searched his family home and reportedly found a trench coat with a damaged lapel and a missing button. Schneider was charged and later indicted for Edward’s murder.
It appeared investigators might have found the break they needed.Then something went terribly wrong.
The button recovered at the murder scene was sent to an FBI laboratory in Washington, D.C., for examination. According to investigators involved in the case, the laboratory lost the button. Without that piece of evidence, prosecutors were unable to establish the connection they believed existed between the crime scene and the coat.
In February 1963, the murder charge against Schneider was dismissed because prosecutors said the evidence could not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. He was released, and no one else was ever charged with killing Edward Kriz.
More than 64 years later, the case remains unsolved.
What began as a routine late-night stop for coffee ended with a husband, father, businessman, and veteran dying in an alley while a masked gunman disappeared into the night. Investigators came remarkably close to putting the case before a jury, but one missing piece of evidence may have changed everything.
Had you ever heard of Edward Kriz’s murder before today? What are your thoughts on such an important piece of evidence being lost during the investigation?
Share your thoughts below, and follow American Dread for more forgotten crimes, cold cases, and true crime stories that deserve to be remembered.
— American Dread
11/09/2026
On November 9, 1998, 81-year-old Mildred “Millie” Clemenson was at her rural home near Kensett, Iowa, preparing for a trip she was supposed to take the following day.
Millie had a plane ticket to Arizona. Friends were expecting her, and everything pointed to her leaving Iowa as planned.
She never made the flight.
Two days later, on November 11, Millie was found dead inside the mobile home attached to the family farmhouse where she lived. An autopsy determined that she had been killed by a blunt-force injury to the head and had likely been dead for approximately two days.
That meant investigators believed Millie was killed on November 9, the day before she was supposed to leave for Arizona.
While friends waited for her at the airport, something terrible had already happened back home.
Millie was well known in the small community around Kensett. Friends and neighbors remembered her as kind and welcoming, someone who enjoyed playing cards and was active with Elk Creek Lutheran Church. She had spent years building a life on the family farm with her husband, Gunder, before his death in 1997.
Then, just over a year later, Millie was murdered inside her own home.
The Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation became involved, and the case generated plenty of questions, but no one was ever charged with killing her.
Today marks 28 years since Mildred Clemenson was murdered.
She had a plane ticket waiting. Friends expected to see her in Arizona. Instead, they were left waiting for someone who would never arrive. Nearly three decades later, Millie’s murder remains unsolved.
Had you ever heard of Mildred “Millie” Clemenson’s case before today? Do you believe someone still knows exactly what happened inside her home that November day?
Share your thoughts below, and follow American Dread for more forgotten crimes, cold cases, and true crime stories that deserve to be remembered.
— American Dread
11/07/2026
For the first time, we’ve put together the full written story of T.J. Davison’s disappearance—a case that’s close to me and still leaves our community searching for answers. I hope you’ll take a few minutes to read his story and share it to help keep T.J.’s name alive.
Read the story here: https://tally.so/r/WOvGrP and check out our website for more podcast episodes, contact emails and much more. americandread.com
TWENTY-FIVE MINUTES The Disappearance of Timothy Jacob “TJ” Davison Made with Tally, the simplest way to create forms.
11/07/2026
In November of 1988, 60-year-old*Betty Rolf left her home in Appleton, Wisconsin, and began walking to work, following a route that was familiar to her and part of an ordinary routine. There was nothing about that morning that should have stood out, but Betty never arrived at work, and before long, concern turned into a search.
The following day, investigators found Betty beneath a railroad overpass in Grand Chute. She had been beaten, sexually assaulted, and strangled. Police collected evidence, interviewed people, and worked the case, but this was 1988, when DNA technology was still limited and investigators did not have many of the tools available today. Despite their efforts, no arrest was made, and as the years passed, Betty’s murder eventually became a cold case.
For her family, however, there was nothing cold about it. They were left with the same question year after year, wondering who had taken Betty’s life and whether they would ever see that person held responsible.
More than three decades later, investigators returned to the evidence using modern DNA testing and genetic genealogy. This time, the science was able to take them somewhere detectives in 1988 could not. Their investigation eventually led to Gene Meyer, who was arrested in 2022 in connection with Betty’s murder.
In 2024, more than 35 years after Betty was killed, a jury found Meyer guilty of first-degree murder and sexual assault.
Betty’s family had waited decades for answers, and while nothing could give them back the years they lost with her, the case finally reached a place many cold cases never do.
Cases like Betty Rolf’s are exactly why we continue talking about unsolved crimes. Evidence can survive. Technology can change. Investigators can take another look, and sometimes a case that seemed impossible to solve can finally move forward.
More than 35 years later, the truth finally caught up.
— American Dread
We truly can’t thank everyone enough for taking the time to like, comment, and share our posts.
Whether you’ve been following American Dread for a while or you’re brand new to the page, we’d love it if you took a few seconds to leave us a review right here on Facebook.
Our Reviews tab is located in the details section near the top of our main page. We actually didn’t realize the feature had been turned off until a few weeks ago, and we’re often asked how people can leave us a review — so now you can.
We truly enjoy reading the feedback we receive across all of the platforms where American Dread is available. Your reviews help us grow and continue getting these stories in front of more people.
Thank you again for the support, and we hope you continue to enjoy American Dread.
11/06/2026
For our first Friday Cold Case Look Back, we’re remembering Sherry Lewis, a 30-year-old Decatur real estate agent whose life was taken on August 5, 1994. Sherry had an appointment to show a home on Finch Drive. That evening, she was found murdered inside the house.
While Decatur prepared for its annual Celebration weekend, Sherry’s family faced a loss that would change their lives forever. Her identical twin sister, Terry, has spent decades fighting for answers and keeping Sherry’s name in the public eye. Thirty-two years later, her murder remains unsolved.
This is why we revisit these cases. An episode may end, but a family’s search for answers continues. Sherry deserves to be remembered, and her family deserves justice.
Listen to “The Finch Drive Murder: Who Killed Sherry Lewis?” under the Cold Cases section at AmericanDread.com. You’ll also find more episodes, contact emails, and case tip forms.
Do you remember Sherry’s case? Please share her story and follow American Dread as we continue keeping these cases in the public eye. - Also follow Justice For Sherry Lewis - Realtor.
PO Box 498, Decatur 62525
Current issue: COMMUNITY SPIRIT Decatur Magazine exists to remind us what it means to take pride in one’s hometown by telling local stories about the people and places that make t...
132 S. Water Street, STE 604, Decatur 62523
Decatur's #1 Hit Music Station!
410 N Water Street, Ste B, Decatur 62523
Decatur's Best Rock: 106.7 The Fox
225 S. Main Street , No. 200, Decatur 62523
Read Decatur, IL and Illinois breaking news. Get latest news, events and information on Illinois sports, weather, entertainment and lifestyles.
410 N Water Street, Decatur 62523
The News and Talk of Decatur, NewsRadio 101 FM! No static, Just Talk! Posting on this page gives us permission to use your thoughts on the air.
1184 S Main Street, Decatur 62522
Millikin University's college radio station! Follow us: Twitter- @WJMUTheQuad Instagram- @wjmu895 Ca
410 N. Water Street Suite B, Decatur 62523
Today's Best Music 93.1 The Party!
363 S. Main Street, Decatur 62525
Serving commercial clients across the United States since 2008, Falcon Multimedia is an award winning video production company based out of central Illinois providing full service ...
1184 W Main Street, Decatur 62522
First Step Records is a student operated record label and publishing company providing hands-on expe
132 S. Water Street, STE 604, Decatur 62523
95Q IS Decatur's Country Home.
Decatur
THIS IS ONLY A BACKUP PAGE 😊
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when American Dread posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
We will notify you when anything happens in Decatur.
Save businesses and follow local categories.
Complete the verification to continue.