Mr P Pizza

🍻 Love at first FLIGHT! ✈️

Why settle for one brew when you can spread your wings and try a few?

Our $12 b**r flights are your ticket to exploring different pours from our rotating craft b**r selection. From crisp and refreshing to bold and hoppy, there’s always something worth taking for a spin.

Whether you’re a frequent flyer or just winging it, we’ve got a flight with your name on it.

Come for the pizza, stay for the flight! 🍕🍺 **rflight

Chef Gage is bringing some serious comfort-food energy to this month’s Sandwich of the Month. 🌶️🥪

Sweet Italian sausage gets piled high with tender peppers and onions, then finished with crisp red cabbage slaw and a drizzle of sweet habanero aioli for that perfect little sweet-and-spicy kick.

Savory, messy, a little fiery, and exactly the kind of sandwich you want to dig into with both hands. Served up with a pile of our house-made chips, because obviously.

Available this month at Mr. P’s! 🔥

A seasonal favorite is sticking around a little longer. 🍕🍎🥓

If you’ve been with us in November, you probably already know Ms. J’s Birthday Pizza. It’s become such a favorite over the years that we decided one month just wasn’t enough.

So for the rest of this year, Ms. J’s Birthday Pizza is taking over the #15 spot on our menu.

It starts with our house-made dough, fresh garlic, shredded Gouda, and Hickman’s hickory-smoked bacon, all baked until the cheese is melted, the bacon is crisp and smoky, and the crust has that signature Mr. P’s finish.

Then we top it with what makes this pizza truly special — Ms. Jen’s famous cinnamon applesauce. Sweet, warmly spiced apples meet smoky bacon, rich Gouda, and garlicky dough for a combination that’s cozy, savory, sweet, and completely addictive.

And for all of our Firecracker Crab Pizza fans — don’t worry. Your favorite isn’t gone for good. The Firecracker Crab will be back next year. 🦀🔥

For now, come enjoy Ms. J’s Birthday Pizza while she holds down the #15 spot through the end of the year. ❤️🍕

A little love letter to the locals who helped make last month’s Pizza of the Month so special. 💚🍕

Figgy Smalls may have left the building, but we couldn’t let it go without giving a huge thank-you to two of our favorite local sources.

The incredible fig jam came from Jam Sessions Jams — sweet, rich, perfectly figgy, and truly the ingredient that tied the whole pizza together. We can safely say Figgy Smalls just wouldn’t have been the same without her jam. If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re seriously missing out.

And a big thank-you to Ray’s Produce for helping us keep things fresh with beautiful local produce. We love having amazing ingredients practically in our own backyard, and we’re always grateful for the people behind them.

Supporting local businesses while creating something our guests loved so much made this one extra special. Thank you to Jam Sessions Jams, Ray’s, and everyone who ordered a Figgy Smalls last month. You showed this pizza A LOT of love. 🖤

Here’s to good pizza, great ingredients, and keeping it local. 🍕🌿🍯

Rainy fall days were made for warm ovens and big bowls of soup. 🍂🌧️🔥

Come get cozy at Mr. P’s, where the wood-fired oven keeps things warm and toasty and the soup is ready to do the rest. Choose our famous Crab & Corn Chowder—rich, creamy, hearty and loaded with comfort—or a bowl of classic Italian Wedding Soup, warm and savory with every spoonful.

Gray skies outside, fire glowing inside, soup on the table. Honestly, we can’t think of a better way to spend a rainy fall day. 🍲🔥

Come warm up with us. 🧡

We know our pizza gets a lot of love — and rightfully so 😏🍕 — but there’s so much more to Mr. P’s than what comes out of the wood-fired oven.

From our hearty chicken cheesesteak to pasta marinara piled high with our meatballs, plus sandwiches, salads, specials and plenty of comfort-food favorites in between, we’ve got something for just about every craving.

Come hungry. We’ve got you covered. ❤️