Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Appleton
Glass Nickel Pizza serves award-winning pies, salads, subs, pastas, homemade lasagna, and more.
Enjoy dining on their expansive patio, grabbing a drink at the full bar, or ordering takeout, delivery, or catering. Few epic duos come close to the greatness of piping-hot pizza and ice cold beer. Our locally-owned and operated restaurant takes this classic comfort combo to the next level with fresh ingredients and high-quality craft brews. If you ever do feel like changing it up, though, we also
08/19/2026
🍕⚡️ APPLETON — WE ARE BACK AND WE ARE BLASTING OFF ⚡️🍕
Tornado tried to stop us… but GLASS NICKEL PIZZA IS OPEN AGAIN and we’re coming in HOT with Y2K TRIVIA on Monday, Aug 24.
💿✨ Think neon, dial‑up internet, boy bands, flip phones, and full‑blown millennium chaos — we’re going BIG for night one.
🪑 Seating: 6:30 PM
🎤 Game: 7 PM
Hosted by Cool Table Trivia (and he’s gonna be ON FIRE tonight)
🏆 PRIZES THAT SLAP:
🥇 $50 Gift Card
🥈 $30 Gift Card
🥉 $20 Gift Card
🔥 FREE APPETIZER ROUND because it’s our first day back and we’re celebrating HARD.
The ovens are roaring, the energy is wild, and the comeback starts NOW.
Let’s PACK the house and make this the loudest Monday we’ve had all year.
Loyalty has its perks. 🍕✨
With Glass Nickel Rewards, every order earns points toward future rewards. Just ask the 2,910 members who redeemed points in July.
Join the club: glassnickelpizza.com/rewards
08/17/2026
08/17/2026
🍕 WE’RE BACK, APPLETON! 🍕
Glass Nickel Pizza Appleton officially re‑opens Monday, August 24 — returning to normal business hours.
Thank you for all the love and patience while we rebuilt.
Come grab your favorites, say hi to the crew, and help us kick off this fresh start.
See you Monday — we’ve missed you.
08/17/2026
Almost 3 weeks since the Tornado hit us and we are still recovering! But the roof is done, the gutters are up, pizza ovens are fixed and dry wall is up in the Kitchen! We got a little more to go! But reopening is coming soon!
08/13/2026
Real ingredients. Real kitchens. Real people who care. 🍕
That's Glass Nickel Pizza.
08/12/2026
🌪️ Tornado Rebuild Update! 🌪️
We’re making progress! 💪
🏠 The roof is DONE!
🔥 Pizza ovens are ½ working — and repairs are on the way, thanks to ASC1!
We’re getting closer every day and are hoping to open our doors sooner rather than later. ❤️
Thank you all for your patience, support, and encouragement while we rebuild. We can’t wait to welcome everyone back! 🍕🍻
Stay tuned for more updates!
08/11/2026
After the tornado hit, we all did the only thing that made sense — we went home. Our employees needed to check on their families, their homes, their neighborhoods. So we unplugged everything, locked up, and left the mess for the next day… including pizzas still waiting to go in the oven.
When we walked back in the next morning, we found something unexpected.
Something… alive.
Something… growing.
Something… very, very doughy.
With all the moisture in the building, our pizza dough didn’t just rise — it mutated. It was wet, melted-looking, and honestly a little adorable. So now we need your help:
What should we name our tornado-born Dough Monster?
08/10/2026
Progress! The roof is getting done! This is the one of the biggest parts of the rebuild, so this is a milestone to reopening!
08/09/2026
Tornado Rebuild Update — Two Weeks Later
It’s been two weeks since the tornado hit our Appleton location, and we want to share where things stand.
The storm caused water damage throughout our kitchen, dining room, and parts of the dish pit. Because of that, the entire affected area had to be fully gutted — every damaged section removed so we can rebuild the right way.
The good news: everything is dried out and ready for the next phase.
We want to give a huge shout‑out to our amazing employees who came in to help clean, clear out damaged product, and empty our coolers and freezers. It wasn’t easy work, but you showed up with heart and determination.
And of course, thank you to Paul Davis Restoration for their fast response, professionalism, and dedication. Their team has been incredible throughout this process.
We’re moving forward, piece by piece, and we’ll keep you updated as the rebuild continues.
Thank you for your patience, your support, and your love for Glass Nickel Pizza. Appleton is strong — and so are we.
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Category
Telephone
Address
2120 West College Avenue
Appleton, WI
54914
Opening Hours
| Monday | 11am - 10pm |
| Tuesday | 11am - 10pm |
| Wednesday | 11am - 10pm |
| Thursday | 11am - 10pm |
| Friday | 11am - 11pm |
| Saturday | 11am - 11pm |
| Sunday | 11am - 10pm |