First Date Coffee Shop
First Date Coffee is a cozy coffee shop in Toms River, NJ, serving specialty coffee, cold brews, refreshers, and sweet treats. Come sip, stay, and enjoy!
Inspired by the magic of first dates, we’re here to create memorable moments, one cup at a time.
I love when people ask me what made us open a coffee shop because honestly?
I think you have to be a little insane to open a business.
You willingly take on stress, debt, long hours, uncertainty, and somehow convince yourself it’s a great idea.
But there’s also something really special about building something that’s yours. Creating a place people enjoy, meeting amazing customers, and watching an idea become a real business.
Would I do it again? Ask me on a day the espresso machine isn’t acting up.
But probably yes.
Today’s the party! 🎉☕️
We’re celebrating our Grand Reopening and we’d love to see you there!
Come hang out, grab your favorite drink, check out some amazing local vendors, and help us kick off this next chapter for First Date Coffee Shop.
We’ve put a lot of love into this little shop and today is all about celebrating with the community that has supported us from the beginning.
📍 First Date Coffee Shop
🕐 Today!
See you soon ❤️
The drink that stole the show at Pride
Our Sunset Pride was such a hit that we couldn’t take it away. Made with mango puree, peach, and lemonade, it’s sweet, refreshing, and tastes like summer in a cup.
If you missed it at Pride, don’t worry it’s officially staying on the menu. 💛🧡❤️
06/17/2026
POV: You stopped by Pride for “just a drink” and somehow left with a full snack lineup 😅🌈☕
Our Pride menu may be gone, but we’re still dreaming about the sunset pride, giant cookies, and banana bread that kept everyone fueled all day long.
Thank you to everyone who came out, supported small businesses, and showed us so much love. ❤️
ShopSmall CoffeeAndCookies
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Category
Contact the restaurant
Address
11 C Washington Street
Toms River, NJ
08753
Opening Hours
| Monday | 7am - 3pm |
| Tuesday | 7am - 3pm |
| Wednesday | 7am - 3pm |
| Thursday | 7am - 3pm |
| Friday | 7am - 7pm |
| Saturday | 8am - 3pm |
| Sunday | 8am - 2pm |