Pizza Shop
Share
The Cosimo’s family tradition begins with a passion for culinary excellence. The Pizza Shop is old school, yes, but not old-fashioned.
It continues with a storied reputation for award-winning cuisine, a legacy spanning more than 50 years. And it culminates today in The Pizza Shop, where passion and tradition meet in a warm, inviting and contemporary light. Recipes that have been in the family for generations have been carefully re-imagined. Familiar dishes have been done a little differently, given new, enticing twists. And, as a
NOW HIRING Dining Room and Counter Servers!
Must be age 18+ and have open weekend availability.
To apply, email Damien at [email protected]
02/23/2026
See you tomorrow! 🍕
02/22/2026
Stay safe and warm ❤️ stay tuned for our hours tomorrow
02/08/2026
ITS GAME DAY! We’re open all day! Call us for your last minute Super Bowl orders! 🏈
02/06/2026
The Pizza Shop has you covered for Super Bowl Sunday! Place your orders today! ☎️ 845-565-SHOP
01/26/2026
See you for dinner! Stay safe and cozy 🍕
01/24/2026
We will be CLOSED on Sunday 1/25 due to the incoming snowstorm ❄️ join us today for lunch or dinner before flakes fly! 🫶🏼 stay safe and warm
12/26/2025
We will be closing today at 5pm due to the incoming storm. Stay warm and cozy 🍕❄️
Friday December 26th
11/21/2025
Vodka Pie Pizza Friday 🍕
11/05/2025
Simplicity 👌🏼
10/25/2025
Pizza Friday 🫡
10/23/2025
ITALIAN CHEESE STEAK | Shaved Ribeye, Mushrooms, Caramelized Bell Peppers & Onions, Provolone, Cherry Pepper Relish
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Category
Contact the restaurant
Telephone
Website
Address
27 S Water Street
Newburgh, NY
12550
Opening Hours
| Monday | 11am - 10pm |
| Tuesday | 11am - 10pm |
| Wednesday | 11am - 10pm |
| Thursday | 11am - 10pm |
| Friday | 11am - 11pm |
| Saturday | 11am - 11pm |
| Sunday | 11am - 10pm |