Lake Effect Ice Cream

Cookie Butter is back at both of our shops!

One of our most requested flavors has returned. Our silky Cookie Butter ice cream is absolutely loaded with Biscoff cookie crumbles, creating the perfect crunch in every bite and keeping you in cookie heaven.

We are starting to think that this one may have to get a permanent spot on our menu.

Stop in today and grab a scoop, cone, or pint while it’s here. Available now at both locations!

Jason and Erik

New Flavor Today: Concord Grape Pie

Now available at both of our shops!

A true taste of our region, this flavor features the bold, sweet-tart flavor of Concord grapes with pieces of flaky pie crust mixed throughout.

Every scoop captures the taste of a classic Concord grape pie, a beloved local tradition.

If you've never tried Concord grape pie before, this is the perfect opportunity to experience one of Western New York's most iconic desserts in ice cream form.

Stop by today and give it a try while it lasts!

Available at both locations.

Jason and Erik

Thank you to everyone who applied to join the Lake Effect team! At this time, all of our positions have been filled.

We truly appreciate the interest and support from our community, and we will keep all applications on file should another opportunity open up in the future.

Today, we remember and honor the brave men and women who gave their lives in service to our country. Their sacrifice made the freedoms we enjoy every day possible.

From all of us at Lake Effect Ice Cream, thank you to those who served, those we’ve lost, and the families who carry their memory forward.

Wishing everyone a safe and meaningful Memorial Day.

Open today:
Lockport 12-9
Buffalo 12-10

Jason and Erik

It’s raining AGAIN!

So we thought a little good news on in order…

IT’S BACK!

Our famous Sponge Candy Ice Cream is returning to Lake Effect Ice Cream this Sunday!

Starting Sunday, you can grab a scoop at BOTH of our shops while supplies last. Rich, creamy ice cream loaded with crunchy sponge candy pieces a true Western New York favorite. If you can’t get into one of our shops, pints of sponge candy will also be available on DoorDash!

If you’ve been waiting for its return, now’s your chance. Stop in and treat yourself!

Available at both Lake Effect locations!

Jason and Erik

This Mother’s Day, at Lake Effect, we want to do something a little special for all the amazing moms out there.

Every mom who stops by on Mother’s Day will receive a small gift bag that includes a stone heart charm and a Lake Effect sticker.

Each heart is a different color, making every one unique… a small keepsake that will last forever and serve as a reminder of how appreciated you are.

We love moms at Lake Effect, and we look forward to celebrating you this weekend!

Jason and Erik

Lake Effect Ice Cream is officially available for DELIVERY through DoorDash at BOTH of our locations!

That’s right, your favorite handcrafted ice cream can now show up at your doorstep without you ever leaving your home!

We’re kicking things off with 10 of our most-loved pint flavors:

Frozen Hot Chocolate
Silver Cloud Vanilla
Paula’s Glazed Donut
Peanut Butter Epiphany
Extra Cookies, Extra Cream
Salty Caramel
Big Wayne’s Cake Batter
Cookie Dough
House Chocolate
Steamworks Coffee

And for those who like a little mystery… yes, our famous Mystery Boxes are available too!

We have just made it that much easier to get your Lake Effect fix!

Whether you're craving a little of our Paula’s Glazed Donut, or some Peanut Butter Epiphany, it’s ready to be sent directly to your doorstep!

Long day? Bad weather? Just don’t feel like waiting in line?

No problem.

Your ice cream fix is now just a few taps away.

Jason and Erik

We get a lot of questions about our ice cream cakes, so it’s time to lay it all out.

The Definitive Guide to Lake Effect Ice Cream Cakes

We keep eight cakes stocked at both locations whenever possible:

CHOCOLATE DREAM
Dark chocolate brownie and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch, topped with chocolate crunch and flake chocolate.

COOKIE DOUGH
Cookie dough and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch, topped with a chocolate chip cookie and mini chocolate chips.

RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE
Raspberry cheesecake and vanilla ice cream layers, filled with vanilla crunch, topped with raspberry candies and raspberry infused frosting.

EL GUAPO (The Handsome One)
Two layers of silver cloud vanilla ice cream filled with cinnamon crumbs, honey, and cinnamon chocolate, topped with cinnamon crumbs, honey, and cinnamon chocolate.

PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE
Peanut butter epiphany and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and crushed Reese’s, topped with Reese’s cups and peanut butter frosting.

SALTY CARAMEL CHOCOLATE
Salty caramel and chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and mini salty caramel truffles, finished with a caramel drizzle.

OREO
Extra cookies, extra cream and vanilla ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and topped with mini Oreo cookies.

TRADITIONAL (with or without happy birthday writing)
Vanilla and house chocolate ice cream layers, filled with chocolate crunch and topped with sprinkles.

Pricing
Small Traditional: $35 (serves 10-12)
Small Specialty: $39 (serves 10-12
Large Traditional: $45 (serves 14–20)
Large Specialty: $49 (serves 14–20)

Custom writing can be added to select cakes with at least one week’s notice. For custom requests, email our amazing cake maker Jo at [email protected]

If you have questions or need help choosing, stop in or send us a message!

Jason and Erik

We’re hiring at our Buffalo location!

We’re looking for motivated team members with strong availability who are ready to jump in and be part of a great team.

If you’re reliable, hardworking, and love a fast-paced environment, we’d love to hear from you.

Interested? It’s easy to apply:

1. Fill out the application attached
2. Take a photo of it
3. Email it to [email protected]
We’re excited to grow our team—apply today or share this with someone who’d be a great fit!

Jason and Erik

We’ve had a lot of people ask so we DO have a very few extra butter lambs cakes and some extra pies available to purchase at each of our locations. All you have to do is ask a staff member and if we have some left, you can grab what you need. All good just got a load

Have a wonderful Easter everyone!

Jason and Erik