Allison Findlay Key West Realtor

✨ Open House Saturday | 12–3 PM ✨
📍 813 Thomas St, Key West

Now offered at $3,895,000

A rare Old Town opportunity on a double lot—beautifully renovated and ready to be seen.

Fresh-squeezed lemonade out front by Titus & Ruby 🍋
Lemonade out front · Step inside



Yann Findlay

🌊 110 Ariola Drive — Pensacola Beach.

Not Key West… but this one really stood out.

Gulf-front, clean lines, and that wide open water you don’t get tired of.
6 bedrooms | 6 bathrooms | ~4,000+ SF right on the sand.

There’s a simplicity to it that just works — easy to enjoy, and easy to see the value.

Happy to share more if anyone’s curious.

Closed. 421 Virginia Street, Old Town.
$3,050,000

A licensed transient property just steps from Duval—offering privacy, a pool, and rare off-street parking in one of Key West’s most sought-after locations.

This closing marks my second transaction with Brenda Donnelly Real Estate—a natural alignment in delivering a higher level of service, discretion, and results.

More to come.

Allison Findlay
305.395.0615

When Ernest Hemingway lived in Key West in the 1930s, he loved sparring and boxing matches. Kermit “Shine” Forbes was Hemingway’s sparring partner during those years. Shine was working with a fighter named Alfred “Black Pie” Colebrooks during a match in a Bahama Village boxing ring when he first met the author.
Until his death at age 84 in 2000, decades after he last sparred with Hemingway, Shine Forbes lived in a small Bahama Village home whose walls bore hundreds of photos and clippings about the author, his descendants, and Key West’s annual Hemingway Days.

Photo circa 1989 by Kevin Crean.

Open House | Old Town Key West

A rare island compound at one of Old Town’s most coveted addresses.

510 Margaret Street
Sunday, February 1 | 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Thoughtfully restored with historic Dade County Pine, vaulted living spaces, and a private guest cottage accessed from its own lane. A tranquil pool courtyard completes this exceptional island retreat.

Offered at $3,595,000

Allison Findlay
Brenda Donnelly Real Estate
305.395.0615

Open House Invitation | 510 Margaret Street

Join us this Sunday to experience an unparalleled island retreat in the heart of Old Town. This meticulously renovated 4BD/4BA compound seamlessly blends historic charm with modern luxury.

Property Highlights:

Main Residence: Restored Dade County Pine walls, striking hardwood floors, and a gourmet kitchen with Thermador appliances.

Outdoor Oasis: A serene private pool with a stacked-stone waterfall.

Guest Cottage: A detached 1BD/1BA cottage with private lane access, perfect for hosting guests.

Event Details: Date: Sunday, February 1st Time: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM Location: 510 Margaret Street, Key West Offered at: $3,595,000

Please visit the link in my profile for the complete property gallery and specifications.
. .

Discover your dream home at our Key West Open House, where luxury meets tranquility.

Join us: Sunday, January 11, 2026
12:00pm - 3:00pm
813 Thomas Street, Key West, FL 33040
Presented by: Allison Findlay | 305.395.0615
Exclusively listed by Brenda Donnelly Real Estate

Experience the ultimate Key West lifestyle in this stunning 4BD/3BA residence, nestled on an expansive double lot in the sought-after X flood zone. Highlights include:
- Wrap-around porches
- High ceilings
- Open living spaces
- Elegant finishes
- Private balcony
- Chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry
- Outdoor oasis with heated saltwater pool
- Guest cottage