Too Pretty To Eat
Custom sugar cookies that are too pretty to eat, but too yummy to not!
09/20/2026
I know it's been a minute since I posted, but I was truly grateful to have a break the first few weeks of the school year. Now I'm ramping up for a busy fall with a western wedding for y'all!
I had fun creating some interesting effects on this hefty order for the rehearsal barbeque - textured denim and woodgrains plus royal icing transfers for both the tags and labels.
Congratulations to Marcus and his bride, Emily! I hope they made it safely to the family farm and everything went off without a hitch!
08/13/2026
A little cutie is on the way! 🍊 And I can't wait to celebrate her! Congratulations, Phelan, Michael, and, of course, Big Sister Gracie!
07/21/2026
What's better than 184 new teachers? 184 new teachers greeted with cookies from the Gilbert Education Association! While it wasn't our usual Welcome Back luncheon, I was thrilled to make a cookie for each and every new certified hire in GPS this year.
We hope to make many more in person connections to share our stories and add more members. Belonging to your professional association is so important and comes with tons of benefits. Remember, you can't buy car insurance AFTER you get into an accident.
Sixteen dozen cookies is A LOT, so I've got a few pictures to help you envision that.
Bonus photo spotted in the new AEA Today: GEA in our new shirts representing our local at the AEA Delegate Assembly in May.
07/04/2026
250 years of independence from a king. Resist, because this constitution won't uphold itself!
06/30/2026
Now, unless you're new here, you know how much I love a good baby shower order...and THIS was a GOOD baby shower order! Besides the fact that I have known this Mommy-to-Be since before the cruise she took as a teenager where she met the Daddy-to-Be, the theme was everything - classic storybooks!
Thank goodness it was summer break, because this set of five dozen took literal days. Lots of royal icing transfers, hand painting, gold painting, and writing. I love the way they turned out, and was so glad I was able to take the order.
Congratulations Tori and Will - Baby Annabeth is sure to be so loved!
06/28/2026
Ack! Ready to post my latest order and realized I had missed one last grad order. These guys celebrated another college Master's graduation. Forks up!
06/06/2026
One more set of twins graduating this season, and my only non-Gilbert high school this year. Some traditional grad designs mixed with a couple things that make these ladies unique. On to big things!
06/04/2026
Traditional grad designs, but the grad herself is gluten-free. Since my cookie kitchen normally does nothing but bake up gluten, I can't promise a completely risk-free product. I do, however, do my best to make sure everything I use is thoroughly cleaned ahead of time and kept separate throughout the whole baking and decorating process. Congratulations, Madison, the last of this year's former Falcon grads!
06/03/2026
Okay, so grad cookies, but make them prettier than grad cookies. 😉 Breaking up my Gilbert High color palette a bit with a softer, more feminine graduation set. I've watched this grad grow from a teeny tiny preschooler to a gorgeous and capable young woman. Congratulations, Olivia!
05/30/2026
Most of my high school graduation orders this year were all for the same school, but none were identical. This first client wanted to add a fun spin - school colors but no cap, gown, or diploma cookies. And my first of two sets of twin cookies this season! I love how these turned out. So fun!
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Contact the business
Telephone
Website
Address
Gilbert, AZ
85295