Too Pretty To Eat
Custom sugar cookies that are too pretty to eat, but too yummy to not!
06/06/2026
One more set of twins graduating this season, and my only non-Gilbert high school this year. Some traditional grad designs mixed with a couple things that make these ladies unique. On to big things!
06/04/2026
Traditional grad designs, but the grad herself is gluten-free. Since my cookie kitchen normally does nothing but bake up gluten, I can't promise a completely risk-free product. I do, however, do my best to make sure everything I use is thoroughly cleaned ahead of time and kept separate throughout the whole baking and decorating process. Congratulations, Madison, the last of this year's former Falcon grads!
06/03/2026
Okay, so grad cookies, but make them prettier than grad cookies. 😉 Breaking up my Gilbert High color palette a bit with a softer, more feminine graduation set. I've watched this grad grow from a teeny tiny preschooler to a gorgeous and capable young woman. Congratulations, Olivia!
05/30/2026
Most of my high school graduation orders this year were all for the same school, but none were identical. This first client wanted to add a fun spin - school colors but no cap, gown, or diploma cookies. And my first of two sets of twin cookies this season! I love how these turned out. So fun!
05/30/2026
Okay, okay....I guess since I just finished decorating the last of the grad orders, I had better get to posting the in between ones! These guys headed across the country earlier this month to celebrate a college grad at an HBCU in North Carolina - Johnson C. Smith University. It's always fun to see my cookies travel so far!
05/09/2026
The first grad order of the season went out the door last weekend. Congratulations, Master Pam!
This is definitely my busy season, and this year I have more than 20 dozen in custom orders for the month of May! (And, in case you're wondering, the answer is no. I am no longer taking graduation orders for this season. I still teach full time, so this is me maxed out.)
05/09/2026
A stogie and a brew before I say I do! After making the cookies for the bride's bachelorette weekend, I was then enlisted to follow up with groomsmen gifts. Twelve groomsmen is a lot of testosterone in one place!
05/09/2026
Playing a little catch up today, and starting with a tenth birthday order for a Fortnite lover. Sometimes you have to get creative with very specific themes, utilizing plaque and basic shape cutters, and turning a llama 🦙 cutter into a Loot Llama! 🪅
04/04/2026
Lots of room for creativity with an egg shape! Play around and have fun... there's no wrong way!
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DWsETC0D2c5/?igsh=MW54ZWdnemtnc3FieA==
04/03/2026
Missed out on pre-orders? I have a couple of spare kits available for pickup this evening or tomorrow morning!
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DWsE06Rj8Jr/?igsh=bjdkdGFuMTRwc203
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Contact the business
Telephone
Website
Address
Gilbert, AZ
85295