Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN

Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN

You may also like

Kiss-zy Hongkong
Kiss-zy Hongkong

Locally owned franchise that has been buying and selling new and quality used inventory since 1992! Kids outgrow sports equipment so fast it’s amazing.

Trade in your used equipment to buy new at a discount, or buy used to save up to 50-70%! Recycle your quality used sports equipment at Play It Again Sports. Much of this gear is still in great condition and has lots of years left in it, which makes that cluttered garage or closet a potential source of income. Cashing in your quality used gear at your local Play It Again Sports is fast and easy:



Elkhart Lions vs NEW PRAIRIE baseball


Elkhart Lions vs Jimtown Jimmies baseball


Black flame pitching machine we just got in yesterday for $79.99! Throws baseballs ⚾️ and softballs 🥎 up to 44mph.


Just in! This 46” Portable Basketball System for your driveway. Grab this and you’ll be the coolest kid in the neighborhood 😎🏰🏀⛹🏽‍♀️


T-Ball is here! Come gear up with our huge selection of bats, gloves, balls, tees, and so much more. Don’t forget to bring in your goodies for potential trade value…go Spring!!!! 🌼🌹⚾️🧢


MVP Glow Craves and Glow Pitches on sale today. Come get yours to commemorate the upcoming eclipse!


Did you know we stock an assortment of skateboards? We have brand new boards ranging from as cheap as $34.99-$99.99. We also have a few longboards as well. Come in and get a new set of wheels to rip around the skate park in style!


Football coaches: we have a few tackling dummies and a tackle wheel in stock. A good find! Come grab it while it’s here!

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 04/01/2024

Brand new Izzo golf push cart for $149.99 also folds up for easy storage or transport!


Happy Easter from all of us at Play It Again Sports Elkhart!

Closed Today.
Monday 4/1 normal business hours.


We have new sunglasses for sale! 9.99 a pair!

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/28/2024

HEY UMP!….Don’t make a bad call! Buying your gear from Play It Again Sports is the right call. New and used umpire gear in stock.


Scotty Cameron Futura 5s, above average (almost mint!l condition, loaded with birdies and eagles during your next round. 🕊️🦅🦆🦜🐥🐓🦢$249 with head cover!


Lefties!! We have a few iron sets still available but WANT YOUR CLUBS! Bring in any clubs hanging out in the garage, on the front lawn, or in your private golf den for some new ones or an old Ping putter! 😱😯🤯🏌🏿


Looking for a smaller compact treadmill that doesn’t take up a lot of space? We just got in this used Proform 300cc treadmill for $299.99.


We have our current bike inventory available at the store. Once the weather warms these bikes move fast. If you’re looking for a new ride come in sooner than later!


Junior golf is here! We have a loaded stock of youth and junior sized clubs. 🏌️ Get your little tyke onto the greens today and get outside!


Our employee Josh was in glove heaven this week when we bought a large collection of high end gloves. If you’re looking for a specific A2000, A2K, Heart of the Hide or Pro Preferred let us know!


Got a little one starting up Tee ball this season? Come see us we have a variety of tee ball Equipment for you to choose from. If you aren’t sure on what all you need to get started no worries we are here to help! we make the process easy and stress free.

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/17/2024

Want to add some drip to your game? Think about doing a flashy relace of your glove like this one. Check out these before and after pics 😍.


We carry a nice variety of EvoShield products including their thumb guards, wrist guards, elbow guards and the ever popular sliding mitts. Come in and check them out and bring in your used baseball gear to trade in!


is here this Spring for your warm weather sports equipment necessities!

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/11/2024

We sell a big variety of lizard skin bat grips. Buy a bat grip from us and we will regrip your bat for free!

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/10/2024

We have our first two kayaks of the year both 10ft. The orange Pelican is $199.99 & the green one is $249.99.

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/07/2024

This beauty just came in. A Rawlings Pro Preferred 12.25”. A glove that, taken care of, will last a life time. This model is used in the majors by former Chicago Cub Kris Bryant. $349.99


We now carry Smackin' Sunflower Seeds! We have all six flavors OG, Backyard BBQ, Churro, Cracked Pepper, Garlic Parm and Dill Pickle! Great to keep in your baseball bag for the upcoming season!


We have a good selection of pickleball equipment for the beginner to advanced players. Join the fun of this new popular sport and get some friends involved.

Photos from Play It Again Sports - Elkhart, IN's post 03/04/2024

We have a huge variety of golf bags right now in stock all ranging from $29.99 to $299.99! And don’t forget we buy used sporting equipment everyday no appointment needed. Just bring in any used gear you aren’t using anymore to trade in towards some new gear.


We have another pocket radar in stock. The last one didn’t last long so if you are interested act fast! Bring in your used items for trade.


Come get them while supplies last! We have loads of new and used baseball/softball bats.

Want your business to be the top-listed Shop in Elkhart?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)

Elkhart Lions vs NEW PRAIRIE HS softball
Elkhart Lions vs Angola Hornets girls gymnastics
Adam is shocked at how amazing our Sparx sharpening machine does sharpening hundreds of skates this weekend. Come check ...
We wax and tune snowboards and skis!  Prices:$40/pair turn around time of two to three days. $60/pair turn around time f...
They don’t call it a Sparx machine for nothing! Don’t forget we sharpen skates. $4 per pair when bought same day from us...
Gear Up
First Skates
NEW Boating Toys are now on sale! 25% OFF all boat tubes, life jackets, water skis, and tow ropes!
Women's Basketball
Huddle Up!
Thank you Ryan for demonstrating the Lobster tennis ball machine. This thing can really launch a ball! 🎾
Brand new Notre Dame apparel! More choices than what's pictured here. Mention this Facebook post and get 50% OFF!.



3527 S Main Street
Elkhart, IN

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm

Other Elkhart shops (show all)
Corazón Sterling Silver from Taxco Corazón Sterling Silver from Taxco
224 South Main Street
Elkhart, 46516

Rediscover the beauty and significance of handmade sterling silver jewelry.

Big and Tall Outlet Big and Tall Outlet
1333 S Nappanee Street
Elkhart, 46516

Big And Tall Outlet sells Big & Tall Men's clothing at 50% of retail. We are located in Elkhart IN.

Matzke Florist Matzke Florist
501 South Main Street
Elkhart, 46516

Matzke Florist - Flowers whisper what words can never say...

Fine! Bead That Way! Fine! Bead That Way!

Unique Jewelry Design At Affordable Prices. We Would Love To Custom Make Something For You!

West View Florist & Gifts West View Florist & Gifts
1717 Cassopolis Street
Elkhart, 46514

In business since 1913. Family owned and operated.

Family Bicycle Center, Inc. Family Bicycle Center, Inc.
3410 S Main Street
Elkhart, 46517

Family Bike... offering professional experience for 41 plus years with new, used, repairs and gear av

Christina's Treasures Christina's Treasures
119 S Main Street
Elkhart, 46516

A beautiful place to shop! If the lights are on we are Open!

Taylor Floor Covering Taylor Floor Covering
53894 County Road 9
Elkhart, 46514

Taylor Floor Covering 53894 CR 9 Elkhart, IN 46514 Tel: 574-264-4354 Fax: 574-262-1236

Gemeinhardt Musical Instruments Gemeinhardt Musical Instruments
3302 Nappanee Street
Elkhart, 46517

Welcome to Gemeinhardt's page!

MMC Discounts MMC Discounts
1210 W Bristol
Elkhart, 46514

A Division of the Midwest Musicians Co-Op, used to raise money for our Lesson Scholarships and Build

The Butt Nugget Cluckin Inn The Butt Nugget Cluckin Inn

Country Themed Candles, Soaps & More

Paolas Custom Paolas Custom