Willy Nilly Trading Company

Willy Nilly Trading Company

Comments

Happy Easter!

We will be Closed Today (Easter Sunday) so that our employees can spend time with loved ones.

From your Friends @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

#HappyEaster #EasterSunday #W***yNillyTrading
Easter Greetings from your Friends @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Our Store Hours this Holiday Weekend:

Saturday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Easter Sunday: Closed
Monday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#EasterGreetings #HolidayHours #ShopLocal #GiftStore #Boutique #LongIslandMemories #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Keep Smiling ...

It makes everyone wonder what you're up to 😉

Fun Fridays Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🙂

Fashion, Clothing, Home Decor, Jewelry, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#FunFridays #KeepSmiling #LoveOurStaff #Smiley #Shopping #Smiles #Boutique #ShopLocal #GiftStore #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Hope you have an EGGcellent Easter 🐰

Our Holiday Hours this Weekend:

Friday: 10:00 am - 6:00 pm

Saturday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Easter Sunday: Closed

Monday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

From your Friends @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#EasterGreetings #StoreHours #EGGcellent #HappyEaster #ShopLocal #GiftStore #Boutique #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Vacation Mode 😎

Sunglasses, Smiles and Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

+ Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Flip Flops, Totes, Hats, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#VacationMode #Sunglasses #Smiles #Shopping #OnlyLongIsland #GiftStore #ShopLocal #Boutique #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Don't Worry ...

Be Hoppy 😊

We are Way too Egg-cited this Week @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🐰

Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#BeHoppy #DontWorry #Eggcited #EasterBunny #ShopLocal #GiftStore #Boutique #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Make it a Magical Mermaid Week 🧜‍♀️

The Hidden Treasures you will find @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Home Decor, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion, Gift and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#HiddenTreasures #Magical #Mermaids #UnderTheSea #GiftStore #Boutique #Gifts #ShopLocal #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #LongIsland #BayShoreNY #W***yNillyTrading
Anchors Away ⚓️

Ocean Inspired Fashion and Handbags @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🌊

+ Home Decor, Jewelry, Gifts, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#AnchorsAway #OceanInspired #Beach #Nautical #Fashion #ShopLocal #Boutique #GiftShop #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #LongIsland #BayShoreNY #W***yNillyTrading
There's no Bunny Like You 🐰

sHopping with my Best Friends @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Home Decor, Candles, Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#sHopping #BestFriends #Bunny #GiftStore #Boutique #ShopLocal #LongIslandMemories #BayShore #LongIsland #BayShoreNY #W***yNillyTrading
Mirror, Mirror on the Wall ...

Who's the Fairest of Them All? 😘

Fun Fridays Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😁

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#FunFridays #LoveOurStaff #Fashion #Clothing #Hats #Boutique #ShopLocal #GiftStore #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
Where's My Cabana Boy? 😎

Time for some Spring Break Fun and Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Fashion, Totes, Clothing, Jewelry, Flip Flops, Handbags, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#SpringBreak #Shopping #CabanaBoy #AllSmiles #FunTimes #ShopLocal #OnlyLongIsland #GiftStore #Boutique #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading
We Love Our Customers 💖

And we Love that you Shop Local 🛍

This is Tina from Copiague enjoying a Spring afternoon Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

#LoveOurCustomers #SpringShopping #TreatYourself #ShopLocal #GiftStore #Boutique #OnlyLongIsland #BayShore #BayShoreNY #LongIsland #W***yNillyTrading

Locally owned & located in downtown Bay Shore, NY, a town enjoying a lively renaissance, we offer an ever-changing selection of Jewelry, Home Decor, Clothing, Bags, Purses, Gifts, Hidden Treasures & so much more.

Relaxing. Inviting. Exactly what you need. Locally owned and located in downtown Bay Shore on Long Island, a town enjoying a lively renaissance, we offer an ever-changing selection of personal and home accessories, catering to the most eclectic tastes with both popular and hard-to-find items. The goal of W***y Nilly Trading Company is to create a relaxing, inviting environment where you can find e

Operating as usual

04/26/2022

Enjoying the Little Things ...

That Make Us Smile @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Fashion, Clothing, Handbags, Home Decor, Gifts, Jewelry and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/25/2022

We Love Our Customers 💖

The Best Kind of Dad is ...

Spending time with his Daughter

And of course Shopping with her @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

All Smiles, this is Xomiyah with her Dad, Freddy from Amityville.

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/24/2022

It's Always Happy Hour 😎

When I'm Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Fashion, Totes, Clothing, Jewelry, Flip Flops, Handbags, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/23/2022

Nothing like a Long Island Weekend 😎

+ Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/22/2022

It's almost Time ...

for some Beach Therapy 😎

Before you go, don't forget your Summer Essentials @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Fashion, Clothing, Beauty, Handbags, Home Decor, Gifts, Jewelry and so much more 🛍

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/21/2022

The Ocean is Where I Belong 🌊

Our New Wall and Home Decor Arrivals @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/20/2022

We Love Our Customers 💖

Family Day of Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

This is Grandma Barbara, Gabby and Lello all from West Islip.

Thank you so much for Shopping Local 🛍

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/19/2022

Long Island

No Place Like Our Home ✨

Thank you for Shopping Local @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Home Decor, Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/18/2022

Mondays ...

Nothing a Bit of Shopping Can't Fix 😎

New Summer Arrivals @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/17/2022

Happy Easter!

We will be Closed Today (Easter Sunday) so that our employees can spend time with loved ones.

From your Friends @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

04/16/2022

Easter Greetings from your Friends @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Our Store Hours this Holiday Weekend:

Saturday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Easter Sunday: Closed
Monday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/15/2022

Keep Smiling ...

It makes everyone wonder what you're up to 😉

Fun Fridays Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🙂

Fashion, Clothing, Home Decor, Jewelry, Beauty and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/14/2022

Hope you have an EGGcellent Easter 🐰

Our Holiday Hours this Weekend:

Friday: 10:00 am - 6:00 pm

Saturday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Easter Sunday: Closed

Monday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

From your Friends @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/13/2022

Vacation Mode 😎

Sunglasses, Smiles and Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

+ Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Flip Flops, Totes, Hats, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/12/2022

Don't Worry ...

Be Hoppy 😊

We are Way too Egg-cited this Week @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🐰

Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/11/2022

Make it a Magical Mermaid Week 🧜‍♀️

The Hidden Treasures you will find @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Home Decor, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion, Gift and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/10/2022

Anchors Away ⚓️

Ocean Inspired Fashion and Handbags @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🌊

+ Home Decor, Jewelry, Gifts, Beauty and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/09/2022

There's no Bunny Like You 🐰

sHopping with my Best Friends @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Home Decor, Candles, Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/08/2022

Mirror, Mirror on the Wall ...

Who's the Fairest of Them All? 😘

Fun Fridays Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😁

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/07/2022

Where's My Cabana Boy? 😎

Time for some Spring Break Fun and Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Fashion, Totes, Clothing, Jewelry, Flip Flops, Handbags, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/06/2022

We Love Our Customers 💖

And we Love that you Shop Local 🛍

This is Tina from Copiague enjoying a Spring afternoon Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/05/2022

The Ocean is Calling ⚓️

Along with Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Home and Wall Decor, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

04/04/2022

We Love Our Customers 💖

Spring Smiles and Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

This is Teagan and Brandon of Islip having fun day out shopping in our store.

The kids are so adorable!

04/03/2022

Dress up Sunday 😊

And Spring Shopping @ Willy Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🐰 🛍

Fashion, Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry and so much more

www.WillyNillyTrading.com

Our Story

Locally owned and located in downtown Bay Shore on Long Island, a town enjoying a lively renaissance, we offer an ever-changing selection of personal and home accessories, catering to the most eclectic tastes with both popular and hard-to-find items.

The goal of W***y Nilly Trading Company is to create a relaxing, inviting environment where you can find exactly what you need and enjoy the shopping experience.

So, how did W***y Nilly Trading Company begin?

Many years ago, a young woman named Marilyn decided to give retail a try so she joined her family’s business, Bay Shore Lighting and Home, which had been started by her parents, Harry and Selma, in 1945. She had found her passion. A few years later, she hired an employee named Lynn and she was perfect in every way, and eventually she became Marilyn’s business partner. You might say it was the proverbial match made in heaven. Marilyn was good at marketing, analysis and numbers, while Lynn excelled at store design and customer relations.

There were some challenging years. Our beloved Main Street, in Bay Shore, where our store is located, faced major vacancies and neglect, but Marilyn believed that revitalization was going to happen somehow. Then in 2000, a friend of Marilyn’s was renovating an historic building in the downtown area and pestered her so much about opening a new store in that very building that she and Lynn came up with a new concept and called it W***y Nilly Trading Company.

Created in just a few months, it opened with an eclectic mix of products including clothing, jewelry, accessories, and gifts of all kinds. In spite of the naysayers who said no one would come, it became a retail destination within a few years.

It soon became apparent that W***y Nilly Trading was a better business than the lighting store (and a lot more fun) so Bay Shore Lighting was closed and in its place Marilyn and Lynn opened W***y Nilly @ Home.

Then in June of 2016, we merged both our W***y Nilly Trading Company and our W***y Nilly @ Home into one combined store. Plus, we added approximately 2,000 more square feet of retail space, we expanded and improved our parking lot and we did so much more in trying to make everyone’s shopping experience as enjoyable as possible.

We hope you pay us a visit soon, and we’ll show you an exciting variety of high-quality products from companies like Alex and Ani, Brighton, Merle Norman and Vera Bradley. If you have any questions, our friendly and knowledgeable staff would love to help, and we’ll show you why it’s best to shop locally.

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

Videos (show all)

Long Island Reversible Compass Necklace
W***y Nilly Trading on News 12 Long Island
Santa Claus at W***y Nilly Trading
Free Umbrella with your $100 Brighton Purchase @ W***y Nilly T...
Silly Scoops @ W***y Nilly Trading
Merle Norman Cosmetics
Merle Norman Cosmetics @ W***y Nilly Trading
W***y Nilly Trading is Toys for Tots Drop-off Location
W***y Nilly Trading is an Official Toys for Tots Drop-off Loca...
Brighton Snap Happy Photo Bags at W***y Nilly Trading
Get Organized with Brighton Handbags at W***y Nilly Trading
Brighton Christo Cuff at W***y Nilly Trading

Category

Telephone

Address


153 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm
Other Gift Shops in Bay Shore (show all)
Sam’s Snapper Design Sam’s Snapper Design
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Sam’s Snapper Designs! All items are custom made, and created by ME.. Samantha Jones. New designs are made daily to incorporate new ideas to please my customers! Feel free to message me for YOUR custom gifts!

The Nascar Store The Nascar Store
1520 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore, 11706

We are an officially licensed NASCAR apparel, Diecast Cars, memorabilia and collectables store.

Om Yogi Om Yogi
1701 Sunrise Highway, D13
Bay Shore, 11706

Yoga/Meditation Gift items from Nepal, Tibet & South Asia. Healing Crystals from around the World.je

Kay Jewelers Kay Jewelers
1701 Sunrise Hwy. Spc. M10
Bay Shore, 11706-6091

Afresh Approach LLC Afresh Approach LLC
Bay Shore, 11706

The most amazing chocolate and candy all custom-made by hand!

Treasure Chest NY Treasure Chest NY
Bay Shore, 11706

We are a family owned business that takes a personal interest in each of our valued customers.

Lost Planet Comics and Collectibles Lost Planet Comics and Collectibles
65 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Lost Planet Comics.

Jewellery & More Jewellery & More
73 Newbrook Ln
Bay Shore, 11706

We sell Good Quality Costume Jewellery & many more accessories !!!!

Long Island Memories Long Island Memories
Bay Shore, 11706

Long Islanders are passionate about the place we call home. Long Island Memories is designed to reflect this special magic through unique products, many of which are available only at our website and sure to delight friends, family or yourself.

Birdhouse Studios 222 Birdhouse Studios 222
Bay Shore, 11706

Hi there, my little chickadees! My shop is all custom orders & run completely on your imagination.