Willy Nilly Trading Company

Willy Nilly Trading Company

Locally owned & located in downtown Bay Shore, NY, a town enjoying a lively renaissance So, how did W***y Nilly Trading Company begin? She had found her passion.

Locally owned and located in downtown Bay Shore on Long Island, a town enjoying a lively renaissance, we offer an ever-changing selection of personal and home accessories, catering to the most eclectic tastes with both popular and hard-to-find items. The goal of W***y Nilly Trading Company is to create a relaxing, inviting environment where you can find exactly what you need and enjoy the shopping

03/18/2024

Still Celebrating 🍀 😉

We Love our Amazing Team Members @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🥰

Gifts, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags, Home Decor, Jewelry, Clothing and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/17/2024

🍀 Happy St. Patrick's Day 🍀

One of our Favorite Posts from last year

This is Ryder who is celebrating the Luck of the Irish with Style 😊

Ryder is a family member of Theresa, our Store Manager @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

So Dog Gone Cute!

www.W***yNillyTrading.com/spring

***yNillyTrading

03/16/2024

Relax and Unwind 😎

Time for Weekend Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Home and Wall Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/15/2024

Home is Where Your Light Is ✨

From our Long Island Memories Collection @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Fashion, Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/14/2024

Our Customer Appreciation Celebration ✨

With Spring Savings @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😎

Visit our website for more details, including how to:

* Save $15 off your next in-store purchase of $75

+ $100 Gift Cards Giveaway

www.W***yNillyTrading.com/spring

Fashion, Home Decor, Jewelry, Clothing, Beauty, Handbags, Gifts and so much more 🛍️

***yNillyTrading

03/13/2024

It's the Middle of the Week ...

Nothing a Bit of Shopping Can't Fix 😎

New Spring Arrivals @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Fashion, Clothing, Handbags, Jewelry, Beauty, Home Decor and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/12/2024

Smile, Sparkle and Shine 😊

Thank You for Shopping Local @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Jewelry, Fashion, Beauty, Clothing, Home Decor, Handbags, Gifts and so much more!

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/11/2024

Hey there, Hop Stuff 🐰

Every Bunny is Welcome @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Home Decor, Candles, Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/10/2024

Just A Girl ...

Who Loves Dogs 😊

New Spring Fashion Arrivals @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Gifts, Home Decor, Clothing, Jewelry, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/09/2024

From our Long Island Memories Collection 🌊

Exclusively Ours @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

+ Home Decor, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags, Jewelry, Clothing and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/08/2024

Special Brighton Springtime Free Gift Offer 🦋

Receive a FREE Brighton Butterfly Garden Tote with your Brighton purchase of $150 or more @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 💖

While supplies last.

Some restrictions will apply. Please see our Store Associates for more details.

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/07/2024

Long Island Road Trip 🚗

Weekend of Shopping Local @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Home and Wall Decor, Gifts, Clothings, Fashion, Handbags, Jewelry and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/06/2024

Treat Yourself to a Little Retail Therapy 🛍

Spring Smiles and Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Clothings, Fashion, Home Decor, Gifts, Handbags, Jewelry and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/05/2024

First Rule of Getting Ready for Spring Break ...

Shop Local @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😎

Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Totes, Hats, Towels, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/04/2024

Don't Worry ...

Be Hoppy 😊

We are really Egg-cited with our Easter Bunny Gifts (and Friends) available @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🐰

+ Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/03/2024

Friends + Family Gather Here ✨

Everyone is Welcome @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/02/2024

Weekend of Savings 😎

Special Spring Clothing Coupon for You 🌸

Save $15 off $75 on your next Clothing Purchase @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

This includes Tops, Pants, Jackets and Dresses.

Discount applies to Full Price Clothing items only.

Sorry, this coupon cannot be used on our Long Island Memories Collection.

Please show this Facebook posting at your time of purchase.

Expires Monday, March 4th, 2024

In-store purchases only.

Limit of one coupon per visit per day.

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

03/01/2024

Alright Spring, do your Thing 🌸🦋

Welcome to March 😊

From your Friends @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/29/2024

Spring Savings Clothing Coupon for You 🌸

Save $15 off $75 on your next Clothing Purchase @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

This includes Tops, Pants, Jackets and Dresses.

Discount applies to Full Price Clothing items only.

Sorry, this coupon cannot be used on our Long Island Memories Collection.

Please show this Facebook posting at your time of purchase.

Expires Monday, March 4th, 2024

In-store purchases only.

Limit of one coupon per visit per day.

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/28/2024

From Under the Sea 🐙

The Hidden Treasures @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) ✨

Home Decor, Clothing, Jewelry, Beauty, Fashion, Gift and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/27/2024

Forget the Rules ...

If you Like It, Buy It 😊

Gifts that are Made for You @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Jewelry, Fashion, Clothing, Home Decor, Handbags, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/26/2024

Long Island 🌊

No Place Like Home @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Wall and Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Handbags, Fashion and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/25/2024

We Turtle(y) Love Our New Arrivals 🐢

Hope to Sea You Soon @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🌊

Home Decor, Jewelry, Fashion, Clothing, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/24/2024

Enough of the Winter Weather 🥶

Think Spring Break @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😎

Fashion, Clothing, Jewelry, Handbags, Hats, Towels, Totes, Home Decor, Gifts and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/23/2024

Island Life 🌊

Show off your Long Island connection 😎

Available Exclusively @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Home Decor, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags, Jewelry, Clothing and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/22/2024

Rainy Days are Made for Shopping ☔️

New Spring Arrivals @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Fashion, Clothing, Home Decor, Gifts, Handbags, Jewelry and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/21/2024

Bunny Kisses, Spring Wishes 🐰 🦋

With Smiles and sHopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 😊

Home Decor, Candles, Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/20/2024

The Ocean Is Where I Belong 🌊

One of our New Wall and Home Decor Arrivals @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

+ Gifts, Jewelry, Clothing, Fashion, Beauty, Handbags and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/19/2024

Despite the Cold Weather ...

Live Like it's Spring 😎

All Smiles and Shopping @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island) 🛍

Fashion, Clothings, Home Decor, Gifts, Handbags, Jewelry and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

02/18/2024

There's No Place Like Home 🐚

The Hidden Treasures @ W***y Nilly Trading (Bay Shore, Long Island)

Home Decor, Gifts, Clothing, Jewelry, Fashion, Beauty and so much more

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

***yNillyTrading

Want your business to be the top-listed Shop in Bay Shore?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Our Story

Locally owned and located in downtown Bay Shore on Long Island, a town enjoying a lively renaissance, we offer an ever-changing selection of personal and home accessories, catering to the most eclectic tastes with both popular and hard-to-find items.

The goal of W***y Nilly Trading Company is to create a relaxing, inviting environment where you can find exactly what you need and enjoy the shopping experience.

So, how did W***y Nilly Trading Company begin?

Many years ago, a young woman named Marilyn decided to give retail a try so she joined her family’s business, Bay Shore Lighting and Home, which had been started by her parents, Harry and Selma, in 1945. She had found her passion. A few years later, she hired an employee named Lynn and she was perfect in every way, and eventually she became Marilyn’s business partner. You might say it was the proverbial match made in heaven. Marilyn was good at marketing, analysis and numbers, while Lynn excelled at store design and customer relations.

There were some challenging years. Our beloved Main Street, in Bay Shore, where our store is located, faced major vacancies and neglect, but Marilyn believed that revitalization was going to happen somehow. Then in 2000, a friend of Marilyn’s was renovating an historic building in the downtown area and pestered her so much about opening a new store in that very building that she and Lynn came up with a new concept and called it W***y Nilly Trading Company.

Created in just a few months, it opened with an eclectic mix of products including clothing, jewelry, accessories, and gifts of all kinds. In spite of the naysayers who said no one would come, it became a retail destination within a few years.

It soon became apparent that W***y Nilly Trading was a better business than the lighting store (and a lot more fun) so Bay Shore Lighting was closed and in its place Marilyn and Lynn opened W***y Nilly @ Home.

Then in June of 2016, we merged both our W***y Nilly Trading Company and our W***y Nilly @ Home into one combined store. Plus, we added approximately 2,000 more square feet of retail space, we expanded and improved our parking lot and we did so much more in trying to make everyone’s shopping experience as enjoyable as possible.

We hope you pay us a visit soon, and we’ll show you an exciting variety of high-quality products from companies like Alex and Ani, Brighton, Merle Norman and Vera Bradley. If you have any questions, our friendly and knowledgeable staff would love to help, and we’ll show you why it’s best to shop locally.

www.W***yNillyTrading.com

Videos (show all)

W***y Nilly Trading on News 12 Long Island
Santa Claus at W***y Nilly Trading
Free Umbrella with your $100 Brighton Purchase @ W***y Nilly T...
Silly Scoops @ W***y Nilly Trading
Merle Norman Cosmetics
Merle Norman Cosmetics @ W***y Nilly Trading
W***y Nilly Trading is Toys for Tots Drop-off Location
W***y Nilly Trading is an Official Toys for Tots Drop-off Loca...
Brighton Snap Happy Photo Bags at W***y Nilly Trading
Get Organized with Brighton Handbags at W***y Nilly Trading
Brighton Christo Cuff at W***y Nilly Trading
Brighton Christo Cuff at W***y Nilly Trading

Category

Telephone

Address


153 W Main Street
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm
Other Gift Shops in Bay Shore (show all)
Kirbysonestopshop Kirbysonestopshop
Bay Shore, 11706

We are a family owned business. We make a variety of different custom made items and are always looking for new ideas and to grow. If we can make your vision happen we definitely w...

Sam’s Snapper Design Sam’s Snapper Design
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Sam’s Snapper Designs! All items are custom made, and created by ME.. Samantha Jones. New designs are made daily to incorporate new ideas to please my customers! Feel f...

Kay Jewelers Kay Jewelers
1701 Sunrise Highway Spc. M10
Bay Shore, 11706

Lost Planet Comics and Collectibles Lost Planet Comics and Collectibles
65 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Lost Planet Comics.

WKND Outpost WKND Outpost
Bay Shore

WKND Outpost, Bay Shore’s first indie lifestyle boutique, is open for business, highlighting smaller brands and emerging designers in a converted garage just off East Main Street i...

Five Below Five Below
1851 Sunrise Highway
Bay Shore, 11706

Long Island Memories Long Island Memories
Bay Shore, 11706

Long Islanders are passionate about the place we call home. Long Island Memories is designed to refl

Birdhouse Studios 222 Birdhouse Studios 222
Bay Shore, 11706

Hi there, my little chickadees! My shop is all custom orders & run completely on your imagination.