My Tomato Pie

Today’s special: Crispy Fried Calamari! 🦑✨

Sorry we sold out this early today. We promise to have more next week. Thanks for an amazing night.

It's that time of year.

Holiday Hours
Christmas Eve: 11am-4pm
Christmas: Closed

✨Gift Card Bonus!✨

Get a special bonus when you treat yourself or family to a gift card.🍕😋

Buy $100+ in gift cards & get a bonus card for $20 off your next visit.

Bonus card sent via email with receipt. Valid 1/1/26 - 2/28/26, Sun-Sat. Use full discount on one check.

Spend more to get more:

Spend $100+, get a $20 voucher.
Spend $500+, get a $125 voucher.

https://order.toasttab.com/egiftcards/mytomatopie

Toast EGiftCards

Join us this weekend. One of our weekends specials. Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread - Tender pulled pork tossed in our spicy peach BBQ sauce, topped with melted smoked gouda and fresh jalapeño peppers on our signature crispy-fluffy pinsa crust. A perfect balance of sweet heat and smoky flavor in every bite.

Amherst - Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread Order Spicy BBQ Pulled Pork Pinsa Flatbread online from Amherst. Tender pulled pork tossed in our spicy peach BBQ sauce, topped with melted smoked gouda and fresh jalapeño peppers on our signature crispy-fluffy pinsa crust. A perfect balance of sweet heat and smoky flavor in every bite.

One of this weekend's specials. Chicken Parmesan Egg Rolls - Two crispy egg rolls stuffed with tender chicken, melted mozzarella, and rich marinara, then brushed with garlic butter and finished with a sprinkle of Romano cheese. A classic Italian favorite with a crispy twist.

Amherst - Chicken Parmesan Egg Rolls Order Chicken Parmesan Egg Rolls online from Amherst. Two crispy egg rolls stuffed with tender chicken, melted mozzarella, and rich marinara, then brushed with garlic butter and finished with a sprinkle of Romano cheese. A classic Italian favorite with a crispy twist.

🔥 Tonight’s Special: Smothered Lemon Pepper Chicken 🔥

Get ready for a flavor-packed favorite! Our Smothered Lemon Pepper Chicken starts with a juicy grilled chicken breast, topped with a creamy blend of artichokes, roasted red peppers, breadcrumbs, and mozzarella. Served over lemon tarragon rice with tender asparagus, and finished with a rich roasted garlic herb butter.

🍋 Creamy. Savory. Irresistible.
Only for a limited time—don’t miss it!



https://mytomatopie.com/order/mytomatopie/item-smothered-lemon-pepper-chicken_32fc0f9c-241d-4ba7-bb58-d18efa559e2d

Indulge in our mouthwatering Boneless Beef Short Rib—slow-braised until fork-tender and served over creamy mashed potatoes with sweet glazed carrots, all topped with a rich demi-glace. The perfect blend of savory and comforting flavors, made fresh just for you!

Tag someone you'd love to dine with tonight! 👇



https://mytomatopie.com/order/mytomatopie/item-boneless-beef-short-rib_79615a81-3fe1-4bed-a664-7336307e3173

✨ New Pasta Special ✨
Sweet meets savory in our Pear & Cheese Fiocchi – delicate pasta filled with pear and cheese, tossed in nutty brown butter, fragrant sage, and topped with Romano cheese. It’s rich, comforting, and totally crave-worthy. 🍐🧈🧀

Available for a limited time — don’t miss this fall-inspired favorite!

Amherst - Pear & Cheese Fiocchi Order Pear & Cheese Fiocchi online from Amherst. Delicate pasta purses filled with sweet pear and creamy cheese, gently tossed in a rich brown butter and sage sauce. Finished with a generous dusting of aged Romano cheese for a savory balance to every bite. A perfect blend of sweet, nutty, and herbac...

Good Friday is here. Last day for our Seafood Lasagna.

My Tomato Pie - My Tomato Pie One of Buffalo's most unique pizza restaurants