Scoota Roche Real Estate

Australia, Winter Is Coming

Post-Covid, New Zealand and Australia left from the same starting line. From March 2020, both markets boomed on record low interest rates and an unprecedented flood of liquidity, both climbing around 40% in a once in a lifetime run.

Four years on, the two could not look more different.

Measured from that same pre-Covid mark, on the same index, here is where they sit today. Australia is up around 47%. New Zealand is up around 17%, and only that high because it is measured from before the boom. From its actual 2021 peak, New Zealand has fallen about 17%, and the worst hit region, Wellington, is down nearly 30%, with the Hutt Valley closer to 32%. Australia kept the boom and built on it, with Perth setting fresh record highs earlier in 2026 alongside Brisbane, Adelaide and Darwin. New Zealand had the same boom and handed almost all of it back. Same start line. Opposite finish.

What drove them apart was policy. New Zealand went hard and fast. The Reserve Bank raised the Official Cash Rate from 0.25% to 5.50% in just 20 months, one of the most aggressive tightening cycles in the developed world. Australia raised gradually and topped out lower, at 4.35%, keeping the good times rolling and, in doing so, prolonging the boom. New Zealand took its punishment early. Australia deferred it.

But here is the turn. New Zealand, and Wellington especially, appears to have hit maximum pessimism. Four years of grinding lower, headline after headline calling the city finished. And maximum pessimism is usually exactly where a downturn ends and a recovery begins. As the old line goes, the moment everyone agrees it is never coming back is usually the moment it does. We saw it in Christchurch after 2011, a city written off, then rebuilt and booming. We saw it in Wellington in the early 2000s, when the capital was flat and forgotten, right before the film industry lit it up and prices ran.

Now turn to Australia. Auction clearance rates have slumped, buyer sentiment has flipped from fear of missing out to fear of overpaying, and over the July 2026 quarter capital city prices actually fell for the first time in this cycle. More and more we are hearing talk of the quietest market in years. In my opinion, this is the beginning of the Australian winter.

And listen to the commentary coming out of it. Agents and buyers advocates are calling it a blip, insisting the market will rebound fast like it always has. Australians are clinging to immigration numbers and supply shortages as proof that no downturn can last. If New Zealand is not a warning of what happens when the tap turns off, I do not know what is. Unfortunately for some, the best time to buy that is being thrown around right now may not be now at all. It may be four years away.

That is the hard news for Australia, if this call is right.

But for New Zealand, it sets up the big reversal. And it may already be starting. The flood of Kiwis leaving for Australia, which defined 2023 and 2024, is now cooling. Departures across the Tasman are easing as Australia's labour market softens, down more than 20% from their early 2024 peak, and net migration has bottomed and begun ticking up. For now the bleed is slowing rather than reversing, but that is exactly how these turns begin. We have seen it before. The last time the outflow peaked and swung back was 2012, right as the Christchurch rebuild pulled people home. If Australia's economy and housing market stall while New Zealand quietly turns the corner, the same thing happens again. The exodus slows, stalls, and reverses, as Kiwis who left for cheaper houses and better wages find the equation has flipped.

So here is the question. Is now the best time in a generation to buy in New Zealand, and the worst time in a generation to buy in Australia?

This is a prediction, not a promise. But history normally repeats itself.

What are your thoughts?

SOLD 📍11 St Francis Grove, Waterloo

One of the best campaigns I’ve been a part of from start to finish. We couldn’t be happier to have achieved what our vendors described as “an awesome result beyond our expectations” 😊

Team RK.. What a year at Ray White Kemeys Brothers

This is some pretty cool feedback from our clients… Unsure about the comparison though 😆🦫

SOLD 📍34A Brees Street, Epuni

This one was a journey, but we managed to get there in the end! Couldn’t be happier for our vendors 🙌

📍42 Bolton Street, Petone

4 bed | 2 bath

One of the finest homes in Petone, this beautifully renovated villa is ready for its next owners to enjoy ✨

📍28 Tilbury Street, Fairfield

3 bed | 1 bath | 1 carport

- Perfect first family home
- Great location
- Modern upgrades
- Double glazing, heat pump & HRV System

For more info get in touch:
Scoota Roche
📞 022 555 3319