MacKay Choristers

It's coming soon. Spread the word!

Throwback Thursday!

Interesting read.

Why Do Singers Unconsciously Switch to Another Part in the Choir?

Have you ever known your choir part perfectly when singing alone, but the moment the full choir starts singing, you suddenly find yourself following another section?

For example, you're an alto, but somehow your voice starts moving toward the soprano line. Or you're a tenor, but when the basses become more prominent, you find yourself drifting toward their notes... Etc

And the funny thing is, you may not even realise you're doing it until someone corrects you.

This is a real choir problem, and it doesn't necessarily mean that you don't know your part.

Sometimes, the problem is that knowing your part and being able to hold your part are two different skills.

KNOWING YOUR PART IS NOT ENOUGH

Imagine an alto who has learned her part perfectly.

She can sing it alone.

She can sing it during sectional rehearsal.

She knows every note and every phrase.

Then the entire choir comes together.

The sopranos begin singing their melody above her. The tenors introduce another line. The basses provide a strong foundation underneath.

Suddenly, there is much more information reaching her ears.

And without consciously deciding to do so, her voice begins to move toward another part.

She may not have forgotten her own notes.

She may simply be responding to what she is hearing around her.

This is why choir singing is different from simply knowing the notes on a page.

When you're singing alone, your musical environment is relatively simple.

In a choir, you're surrounded by multiple simultaneous musical lines.

Your job is not only to know which notes belong to you.

Your job is to maintain your musical line while hearing everything else that is happening around you.

YOUR EAR CAN PULL YOUR VOICE TOWARD ANOTHER PART

This is where your listening ability becomes extremely important.

When another section is singing a prominent melody, your ear naturally notices it.

If that melody is familiar, strong, or easier for you to hear than your own part, your brain may begin giving more attention to it.

And if you aren't sufficiently anchored to your own musical line, your voice can start following what your ear is hearing most strongly.

This can happen almost unconsciously.

You aren't necessarily thinking:

“I want to sing the soprano part now.”

Your voice simply begins moving in that direction.

That is why some singers say:

“I don't know why I keep switching parts. I know my part.”

Exactly.

Knowing the part isn't always the problem.

The challenge is maintaining it while other parts are competing for your attention.

LISTENING TO THE CHOIR DOESN'T MEAN FOLLOWING THE CHOIR

This is an important distinction.

A good choir singer needs to listen to the other sections.

But listening to them does not mean following them.

You need to be aware of the entire harmony while remaining anchored to your own line.

Think about it this way.

You should be able to hear the soprano.

You should be able to hear the tenor.

You should be able to hear the bass.

You should be able to hear your fellow altos.

But while hearing all of them, your brain still needs to know:

“This is my line.”

That is a much more developed form of choir listening.

You're not shutting out the other parts.

You're learning how to hear them without allowing them to take control of your own part.

WHY SUSTAINED NOTES CAN EXPOSE THE PROBLEM

This problem can become particularly obvious during sustained chords.

Imagine that the choir holds a chord.

Your section is holding one note while another section moves through a melody above you.

Because the other part is moving, your ear may naturally follow that movement.

Meanwhile, your own note is remaining steady.

If you aren't sufficiently aware of your own pitch, you may begin moving with the other section.

Sometimes the movement is obvious.

Other times it is subtle.

You may only move slightly away from your original note.

But even a small movement can affect the harmony and make your section less distinct.

This is why holding your part is not simply about memorising the melody.

It is also about developing the ability to remain stable while other musical information is moving around you.

YOU DON'T HAVE TO SING LOUDER TO HOLD YOUR PART

Some singers respond to this problem by trying to sing louder.

They think:

“If I sing louder, I'll be able to hear myself and I won't lose my part.”

But that can create another problem.

You may become unnecessarily loud, tense, or dominant.

The goal is not to overpower the choir so you can hear yourself.

The goal is to develop enough internal and auditory awareness that you know where your part is even while you're hearing the other sections.

There will certainly be situations where you need enough volume to hear yourself appropriately.

But volume should not be your primary strategy for maintaining your part.

Awareness is more important than force.

HOW DO YOU GET BETTER AT THIS?

Start by becoming more familiar with your part than simply memorising the notes.

Learn to hear your line internally.

Know where your part moves upward and downward.

Know where it stays.

Know which phrases are similar to another section's melody.

Pay particular attention to places where your part comes close to another section's notes.

Then practise your part while deliberately listening to another section.

For example, if you're an alto, you can listen to the soprano line while continuing to sing your alto part.

The goal isn't to ignore the soprano.

The goal is to prove to yourself that you can hear the soprano without abandoning your own musical line.

Over time, this can strengthen your ability to maintain your part inside the full harmony.

DON'T ONLY ASK, “DO I KNOW MY PART?”

Ask a better question:

“Can I hold my part when everyone else is singing?”

That is the real test.

You may know your part perfectly in isolation.

But choir singing happens in a musical environment.

So your training should eventually prepare you for that environment.

Practise your part alone.

Practise it with your section.

Practise it with the full arrangement.

And when possible, practise while deliberately exposing yourself to the other parts.

You're teaching your brain:

“I can hear all of this information and still remain anchored to my own line.”

That is a valuable choir skill.

THIS IS ALSO WHY BLENDING REQUIRES A TRAINED EAR

Interestingly, the same listening ability that helps you hold your part also helps you blend.

A singer who is only listening to themselves may sing the correct notes but still stick out of the choir.

They may have a different vowel.

They may have a brighter or heavier tone.

They may be louder than necessary.

They may pronounce consonants differently.

They may simply have a different sound balance from the people around them.

You need to hear the whole group to recognise these differences.

So choir listening has two sides.

You need enough awareness to maintain your identity within the harmony.

But you also need enough awareness to adjust your contribution so that it works with the group.

That's why good choir singing is not simply:

“Sing your part.”

It's:

“Know your part, hold your part, and understand how your part fits into the whole.”

THE BIGGER LESSON

If you find yourself unconsciously switching from alto to tenor, soprano to alto, tenor to bass, or any other part, don't immediately conclude that you don't know your music.

Ask yourself what is happening when the full choir enters.

Are you losing your internal sense of your own line?

Is another section much louder than yours?

Are you following a familiar melody?

Are you struggling to hear your own section?

Are you listening to the other parts without remaining anchored to yours?

Those questions can help you identify what is actually happening.

And once you understand the problem, you can train specifically for it.

Because the solution isn't always:

“Learn your part again.”

Sometimes you already know it.

You simply need to learn how to hold it.

THIS IS WHY I WROTE CHOIR SECRETS

This particular issue is one of the reasons I wrote my booklet, CHOIR SECRETS — 5 Truths Nobody Told You About Harmony, Blending & Choir Clarity.

Truth 2 is titled:

“Knowing Your Part Is Not Enough — You Must Hold It.”

Because in a real choir, knowing the notes is only the beginning.

Other voices will be singing around you.

Melodies will move.

Harmonies will change.

Volume levels will shift.

Your attention will be divided.

And through all of that, you still have to maintain your musical line.

If you've ever experienced yourself unconsciously following another section, this is one of the choir issues you should understand more deeply.

You don't just need to know your part.

You need to develop the ability to hold it.

And that's a very different skill.

❤️ NE🎤
HAPPY SINGING❤️

Coach Victor | VOOM
Founder & Lead Vocal Coach
VOOM Vocal Academy

CHOIR SECRETS — 5 Truths Nobody Told You About Harmony, Blending & Choir Clarity
Available from VOOM Vocal Academy.

If you're looking for a choir, mark this on your calendar and come check us out ....

Mark it on your calendars, we're starting up again.

This was a fantastic concert. They make singing in a choir look so enjoyable and easy!

Good for you Marjorie!

✨ 2016 doesn’t feel that long ago… until you realize it’s been a full decade.

Ten years ago, Marjorie Duizer joined the IODE Maple Leaf Chapter. Since then, she’s been part of ten years of friendship, service, community projects, and making a difference close to home.

This month, we celebrated her 10-year membership milestone and reflected on all that can be accomplished when someone chooses to invest their time and talents in their community.

Congratulations, Marjorie, and thank you for being part of our story. ❤️🇨🇦 🎉 💙

Choir dogs. 😎

Let's play! 😂