Bakeries in Webster, NY

Find bakeries in Webster, NY. Listings include Simply Sweet by Kay, Secret Ingredient Cupcakery, Kiss Me Cookie, Scottish Shortbread Company, Sweet Shenanigans, Off The Cuff Home Kitchen.

Bakeries [14] Donut Shops [3] Cupcake Shops [1] Bagel Shops [1]

Michele's Own Delights by Michele O'Kipney Dougherty
Webster, 14580

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Webster, NY?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

A Simply Sweet by Kay
Webster, 14580

Placed as GOLD winner of Community Votes Rochester 2025 thanks to all of you! <3

B Secret Ingredient Cupcakery
1991 Empire Boulevard
Webster, 14580

Fresh cupcakes baked daily by a lady who loves making your day a little sweeter 💙 Special order for all occasions 🎂🔔👶🎓🎉 Brownies, Pup Cakes, Cookie Sandwiches and Gluten Free/Vegan...

C Kiss Me Cookie
15 East Main Street
Webster, 14580

D Scottish Shortbread Company
700 Ridge Road
Webster, 14580

Traditional homemade Scottish Shortbread. Bakery Hours Tuesday - Friday, 9-5 Saturday, 9-3

E Sweet Shenanigans
15 E Main Street
Webster, 14580

F Off The Cuff Home Kitchen
Adams Road
Webster, 14580

Off The Cuff Home Kitchen is a NYS approved home kitchen, based in Webster, NY. Owned by Louise Johnson, British born, offering a large variety of homemade baked goods, & snacks. ...