Paper Doll Vintage Boutique

Voted LI's #1 Best Vintage Shop in 2013-24 by LI Press! 23 Main St, Sayville NY. Each piece is hand selected and inspected to be in excellent condition.

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique carries wearable one of a kind clothing from all decades from the last century, through high end designer pieces. Some unique hand made goods also adorn the shop's shelves. Personal, editorial and film styling are also available! If you are looking for something unique or are a vintage lover, Paper Doll Vintage Boutique is your one stop shop to get all dolled up!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/20/2024

UP FOR GRABS! 🌞🌞🌞 1990s Christian Lacroix Jumbo Golden Sun Brooch. This gorgeous surrealist inspired brooch features a golden plated jumbo sun design which includes a face! Locking safety catch clasp closure. The "LC" Christian Lacroix stamp can be found on the back of the brooch. Flaws to note: Some areas of wear to the metal. (Please see photos)

Length: 4in
Width: 4in

$549 + Ship or pick up in-store! Now on our website!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/19/2024

Butterfly prints never go out of style! Pairing these vintage PRADA leather boots with a silky satin maxi skirt and short sleeve solid color stretchy top for a grunge 90s look! This outfit is also accessorized with a leather and woven canvas backpack and floral charm necklace. All available at the shop! 🦋

+1990s Butterfly satin skirt - Size small $64.99 Waist: 26in
+ 1990s Stretchy shirt Size Sm/med $34.99 Bust 32in-40in
+ Y2K Leather PRADA boots Size 9.5 $99
+ 1990s Leather & canvas backpack $46
+ 1970s Janny Flower Charm Necklace $38

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/18/2024

Did you know that the designer brand Lanvin is 135 years old and founded by Jeanne Lanvin, a female fashion designer who started her career in fashion as a hat milliner? This bright and beautiful 1970s Lanvin shirtwaist dress adorned with colorful paisley prints is one of our favorite Lanvin pieces we have here at the shop currently! Accessorized with a stretchy jumbo buckle belt, beaded necklace, matching blue leather slides and a clutch!

+ 1970s Lanvin Jumbo Collar Shirtwaist Dress Size M/L $160 as-is. Bust 39in, Waist 36in, Shoulder 15in, Hip 40in
+Y2K Stretch Belt $16
+1990s-Y2K Slides $30
+1970s Beaded chain necklace $18
+1960s-70s convertible clutch $24.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/17/2024

UP FOR GRABS! 🍦⭐🍦1990s FIORUCCI Ice Cream Pop Satin Square Scarf. This outrageous Italian pop-art inspired printed scarf features a bright green ice pop overlayed on a bright pink background. "Fiorucci" can be found on the tag sewn to the scarf as well as printed on the ice-pop stick graphic. Machine stitched hem. Material tag reads 100% Acetate. Flaws: various stains and snags throughout. (Please see photos) Sold as-is.

Length: 26in
Width: 26in

$99 + Ship / or pick up in store. Now available on our website!


Loads of vintage t-shirts are hitting the shop floor this week, including this perfect Father's Day Snoopy one! Come in and check them out in person before they hit the website! 🎸⚡️

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/15/2024

Looking for the most silly and hilarious cufflinks or tie clips for a gift? We have them! 😛 These accessories make the perfect gift for Father's Day!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/15/2024

Calling all rare vintage band tee collectors! Do we have some cool pieces for you! Check out this collection of rare Bowie, Ozzy & New York Dolls T-shirts! The David Bowie T-shirts are parking lot bootlegs! ⚡️🕷

+ 1987 David Bowie Spiders Tour XL - $200
+ 1990s Sound&Vision Tour XL - $300
+ 2003 Ozz Fest M/L - $89
+ 2004 New York Dolls Re-Print Shirt L - $64.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/14/2024

Looking for the perfect Father's Day gift ideas? We have lots of gorgeous designer men's ties to choose from! Emilio Pucci, Oleg Cassini, Givenchy, YSL & more! 👔

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/13/2024

Denim and rhinestones for days! ✨ Check out this awesome 1980s rhinestone and studded jacket with custom branded buttons! Accessorized with a Y2K mini purse, 90s hair bandana & some retro sunglasses. All available at the shop!

+1980s - 1990s Don't Stop Silver Studded Denim Jacket Sz Med/Large $89
Measurements: Length: 27", Bust: 41", Shoulder to shoulder: 18", Sleeve Length(pit to cuff): 18"

+ Retro sunglasses $15
+ 1990s lace tie bandana $20
+ Y2K Guess Purse $38
+ Y2K stretchy knit top Sz Small $34.99


UP FOR GRABS! ✨✨✨1950s Jumbo rhinestone adjustable necklace! This glamorous piece features rows of round and rectangle cut rhinestones set in silver tone metal. The clasp closure is a hook which makes this piece super adjustable and can be even adjusted into a choker!

Length: 16in
Width: 1.625in (at widest)

$148 + Ship or pick up in-store!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/12/2024

Picking out the perfect vintage outfit for your next summer getaway vacation? Check out this 1970s purple & red light knit low rise pants and halter crop top SET! The color combo on this rare piece is outrageous! Paired with some mod & psychedelic accessories to make the whole look pop!☀️🌈✨

+ 1970s Knit halter top and pants SET $249 Size Small, Bust 30in- 34in, Waist 28 - 30in, Hip 36 - 40in, Rise 8.25in
+1960s Op art travel bag with compartments $55
+ 1970s Italian wooden and patent leather slides Sz 5 $89
+ Retro sunglasses $15
+ 1970s Woven straw bracelets $12 each
+ 1970s Silk psychedelic floral scarf $24.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/11/2024

UP FOR GRABS! 🐟🌞🌊 1996 TRIFARI Limited Edition Dated Seahorse Figural Brooch. This gorgeous limited edition reissued brooch by Trifari features a golden seahorse design inlayed with colorful rhinestones and a red glass cabochon eye. Locking safety catch clasp closure. "Trifari TM 1996" stamp can be found on the back of the brooch. Flaws to note: Missing turquoise rhinestone on the top of the brooch. (Please see photos.)

Length: 2.5in
Width: 1.25in

$189 + US/ Intl shipping. Available on our website! Link in bio.

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/10/2024

Summer is our favorite season here at the shop! We love all of the floral and pretty lace tops we have available that are perfect for this warm weather! ☀️🌤⛅️

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/09/2024

Our plus size vintage rack is jammed pack with all new summer goodies! Check out all these cute tops & bathingsuits that are available! 🌟

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/08/2024

Rainbow floral perfection! 🌸🌸🌸 This 40s - 50s dress is constructed of a multicolor watercolor floral print cotton fabric. It features a scoop neck neckline, cap sleeves, fitted waist, optional belt, pencil skirt, and zipper closure on the back of the dress. This piece is in excellent vintage condition with no noteworthy flaws. Accessorized with a 1930s celluloid clasp bag, rhinestone heel bow detail spring-o-lator shoes, 1960s straw hat, beaded necklace and pink poly scarf!

Dress Measurements: Size XS, Length: 38", Bust: 33.5", Waist: 23.5", Shoulder to Waist: 14.5" Hips: 35" $99

+1930s Celluloid Black And White Wood Beaded Chain Handle Kiss Lock Purse $148.99
+1960s Straw wide brim pink hat $36
+1950s Rhinestone Spring-o-lator heels Sz 7.5 $134
+1970s Pink Poly Scarf $24


UP FOR GRABS! 1960s - 70s JANNY Cherry charm chain link necklace and pierced earring SET! This beautiful dainty necklace features red clustered beads hanging from a figaro style chain. The earrings have pierced posts and matching red beads!

Chain measures 16.25in. Earrings are 0.75in in length.

$48.99 + US/intl ship. DM if you are interested or come visit us in-store!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/06/2024

Summer knits! ☀️🌤🌥 Check out this super adorable 1960s-1970s red, white and blue pin stripe 2 piece cardigan & mini dress set! Paired with some vintage skates, straw hat, nautical scarf and crochet bag. Wear the mini dress alone or alongside with the cardigan on cooler days!

+ 1960s - 1970s Stagwhites Knit Tennis Mini Dress and Cardigan 2 Pc Set. As-is. Size XS-S, $249
+ 1970s skates size 9.5US $40
+1950s crochet bag, made in France, with tags $14.99
+ 1950s-60s nautical scarf $16
+ vintage straw boater hat $34.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/05/2024

UP FOR GRABS! 🌸🌸🌸 1950s Mary Scott Rowland Round Silver Floral Jumbo Compact. This beautiful silver tone compact features a swirling design of embossed flowers. No makeup inside. "Mary Scott Rowland" stamp inside compact lid as well as on powder applicator. Flaws to note: Some areas of the metal around the compact have been scuffed revealing a dark patina. Powder applicator is flaking from age. (See photos). Mary Scott Rowland was an important figure in American cosmetics history! The inventor of the first American compact in the late 1800s. She paved the way for other companies creating the mirror, powder multi-use compact we know and love today! A true collectors item!

Approx: 4in x4in

$68.99 + Ship or pick up in store! Available on our website! 🌸


This 1960s raffia crochet hat & bag two piece set is so outrageously cute! The bag is a bright lemon yellow and the hat is white with the same matching 3d flowers! Sure to brighten up any outfit! Now available at our shop or DM if interested. 🌼🌼🌼

1960s Raffia Crochet Hat & Bag SET $99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/04/2024

All new summer arrivals are hitting our online shop, including this gorgeous psychedelic stunner! This 1960s one piece jumpsuit features colorful print, a mock neck, bow detail and a super wide palazzo pant! Accessorized with a bright blue top handle bag and a collectable Peter Max art book!

Jumpsuit available on our website, link in bio! 🦋

+ 1960s Psychedelic Jumpsuit Size small $224
+ Peter Max Art Book Of Peace $50
+ 1960s Blue Top Handle Bag With Rhinestone Detail $44
+ 1960s Ombre Blue Graduated 3 Strand Beaded Necklace $34.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/03/2024

Bright and colorful 1990s and Y2K pieces have arrived to our shop this week! We've adorned our racks with animal prints, lacy and floral vintage goodies! 🦋🦋🦋

In this photo:
+ Y2K-90s Stretchy top - Sz med/lg $34.99
+ 90s-Y2k Velvety zebra print skirt with turquoise fringe trim - sz small 26in waist, $74.99
+ 1990s Nena beaded handle tassel detail bag - $34
+ Y2K Rainbow necklace $14.99
+ 1990s-Y2K Two Lips wooden platform sandals - sz 9M $68.99
+ Retro Sunglasses - $15
+ 1990s hair clips - $1 each

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/03/2024

UP FOR GRABS! This 1950s - 60s woven straw top handle purse makes for the perfect summer accessory/ travel bag! Woven yarn details and a unique woven radial design. Leather and metal twist lock closure. Tag reads "Mexico" Bag is structurally sound. Flaws to note: One of the 3d straw flowers are missing from the front. Straw in an area on the top of the bag is slightly fraying.

Length: 11in (at tallest)
Width: 13in (at widest)
Depth: 3in

$68.99 + US/ Intl ship. DM to purchase or for more information! Local? Pay now and pick up in store or come shop in person!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/02/2024

1960s mod bubble gum dream! Check out this vintage pink and white plastic beaded purse! Made in Italy. Certainly inspired by Paco Rabanne's famous disc dress! Has a few scuffs & marks in areas on the white discs from wear. Great vintage condition. All beads are intact. Structurally sound and ready to wear!
Hasn't hit our website yet so here's your chance before it's listed!

$54.99 + US/Intl ship. DM if interested or for more information! Local to NY? Come visit us in store!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 06/02/2024

1990s YOHAI Signed Golden Swirl Bracelet. This gorgeous bracelet features a decorative swirl chain link design created in a luxurious brushed golden metal. The closure of this piece is a loop through, which features a decorative charm. The "YOHAI" signature can be found on the closure. Flaws to note: Some areas in between the links have had the metal worn from wear. (Please see photos)

Length: 7in
Width: 1.5in (at widest)




Happy 1st day of June! We're stocking up some super cute vintage summer footwear! Sandals, flip-flops, loafers, platforms and more! Check out this colorful selection of vintage sandal slides! 🌈🌈🌈

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 05/31/2024

A psychedelic dream! 🌼🌸🌷 This bright and colorful 1970s jumpsuit makes for the perfect summer outfit for any music festival or day out! Pair it with a vintage straw hat, vintage beads and contrasting white belt!

+1970s Multicolor Psychedelic Floral Print Wide Leg Jumpsuit - Bust: 36", Waist: 34", Hip: 42", Inseam: 31", Shoulder to crotch: 27" - $119
+1980s Plastic Belt $28.99
+1970s-80s Straw Hat $34.99
+1970s Peck and Peck Scarf $18
+1960s Lucite Necklace $22

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 05/30/2024

Fresh restock over at Rosie's Vintage!

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 05/30/2024

The perfect beach attire! ☀️☀️☀️

1950s - 60s 2 piece swim suit size small - $99
1960s Straw hat - $34.99
Retro sunglasses $15
1990s White headband $8
1960s-70s wicker bag $36.99
1980s Sarong/ beach wrap $34.99

Photos from Paper Doll Vintage Boutique's post 05/29/2024

Fun in the sun! 🌞🌞🌞 Browse our entire collection of vintage swimsuits and sunsuits here at the shop! Check out this gorgeous VOLUP psychedelic Catalina swimsuit paired with the perfect accessories for hanging out at the beach!

+ 1960s Catalina Swimsuit - Length: 31.5" , Bust: 38", Waist: 29"-32", Hips: 37"-40" Sz XL $99
+ 1970s Smiley face / sad face stand up tote $38
+ Retro Sunglasses $15
+ 1990s Blue Straw Hat $24.99
+ Assorted stackable bangles 4 for $15
+ 1970s - 80s Large striped sheer blanket/shawl $30

As always, we do ship! DM us for more information!

Want your business to be the top-listed Shop in Sayville?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)

paperdollsale Memorial Day Weekend SALE at both Paper Doll stores! BOGO 50% OFF at Paper Doll Vintage Boutique and 50% O...
Mothe’s Day gifts-a-plenty at Paper Doll! #vintage #mothersday #mothersdaygift #mothersdaygifts #vintagemothersday #vint...
I never knew the coordinating outfits from the 1960s and 70s had the pieces arrive at seperate times, with a wait to nab...
Our shop’s newelst decade rack- Y2K-2010! #fashion #style #y2k #2000 #y2kvintage #vintagefashion #vintagestore #longisla...
Springfest today until 4pm! And we are open until 8! #springfest #sayville #funforthewholefamily #longisland #lirr #pape...
Re-organizing the special garments rack and behind the counter storage. #vintagedesigner #designervintage #springcleanin...
Sprinkling some re-stock of vintage clothing in at Rosie's Vintage! Great to see my vintage treasure friends! I apprecia...
$5 Fill-A-Bag starts this weekend at Paper Doll Vintage Boutique! #paperdollvintage #paperdollvintageboutique #newyorkvi...
$15 Fill-A-Bag sale at Paper Doll Vintage Boutique! #vintagesale #vintage #newyorkvintage #nyvintage #longislandvintage ...
We are delighted to bring you the largest collection of Miriam Haskell jewelry we have ever come across! Miriam Haskell ...



23 Main Street
Sayville, NY

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 6pm
Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 7pm
Friday 11am - 8pm
Saturday 11am - 8pm
Sunday 11am - 6pm

Other Sayville shops (show all)
Seafarer Gift Shop Seafarer Gift Shop
28 S Main Street
Sayville, 11782

WEBSITE & BLOG! Visit: We have left our S

Attias Flea Market Attias Flea Market
5750 Sunrise Highway
Sayville, 11782

The Sayville Chocolatier The Sayville Chocolatier
6 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Sayville's Premier Chocolate Shop since 1980!

Out  of  the  Blue Out of the Blue
89 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Unique accessories

Irish Crossroads Ltd. Irish Crossroads Ltd.
58 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Irish Gifts - Claddagh Rings & Celtic Jewelry - Belleek China - Aran Sweaters - Irish foods & teas -

Tracy Made It Tracy Made It

Personalized Tees, bracelets & Disney Ears.

Everly & Co. Boutique Everly & Co. Boutique
116 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Costello's Rare Coins Costello's Rare Coins
146 Railroad Avenue
Sayville, 11782

Specializing in rare coins/numismatics World coins, Ancient coins, U.S coins, Bullion, Antiques, Historical Documents, Etc. Always buying & selling

ExcellRent Mobile Restrooms ExcellRent Mobile Restrooms
Sayville, 11782

Luxury restroom rental company located on Long Island, New York.

Little Shoppe of Crystals Little Shoppe of Crystals
12 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Sayville’s own Little Shoppe of Crystals. We specialize in hand picked crystals and gemstones. Coming soon ... Nov 2020.

Park Avenue Rarities Wholesale Park Avenue Rarities Wholesale
173 N Main Street Suite 232
Sayville, 11782

Park Avenu Rarities has been in business for over 11 years. We have been serving our community with all their numismatic needs with great success. Come find out why our customers s...

Wondrous Candles & Soaps Wondrous Candles & Soaps
126 Main Street
Sayville, 11782

Natural, Vegan & Eco-Friendly Candles, Soaps and Bath Bombs. Made in the USA. Wondrous Moisturizing