Butter Custom Bakery, LLC

Butter Custom Bakery, LLC


My son LOVED his birthday cake from Butter Custom Bakery!! Thanks a bunch Kaitlyn!
Hi Butter Custom Bakery, LLC, Your cake seems to be on page [11] here https://bit.ly/2ZUV0TV. How you take part on this?
Thanks for the rock and roll birthday cookies. They looked and tasted great!
Join us in the Here For Good campaign to help keep local businesses here for good.

It's simple, and is zero risk, zero inventory, and you get all the profit to help keep your bills paid, your staff on board, and your business moving forward.

1. Email us your logo. *You can either have your logo on the tshirt or a fun or motivational or quirky saying with your logo underneath.

2. Let us know what T-shirt color you would like.

3. Choose the ink color you would like for the design. Up to 2 ink colors available.

4. We will design your shirt and upload it to the website and email you a link. Then all you have to do is e-mail the link or post it on social media and let your costumes and audience know about the campaign. You will get $10 from every tshirt sold.

Here is a link to the campaign page with other businesses - https://shop.envisiontees.com/here-for-good/shop/home

Looking forward to helping you in this time of need, we're all in this together.

Thanks. Tracy
We may not be the best at decorating them, but we are great at eating them! Thanks, Kate!
Our son's birthday cake was adorable and tasted amazing! Everyone asked where we got it. Highly recommend!
Come on down to Makers Loft off of the Ped Mall! Open until 5 p.m.
Thank you Butter Custom Bakery for an amazing birthday cake!!!!
How adorable are these?!?! Thank you so much for the amazing cupcakes for my daughter's birthday party!!

Neighborhood bakery offering a daily selection of cake donuts, muffins, cookies, cupcakes, and more,


Lots of fun Easter goodies in the shop today! Hop on over… we’ll be here until 3pm!🐣🐰🥚🐰🐣




It’s not too late to order hot cocoa bombs! They make great stocking stuffers or gifts for teachers, neighbors & friends!


Order on our website today (12/22) for pickup tomorrow (12/23).

We will be closed 12/24 & 12/25.


Happy 4th of July weekend! We will be closed today for a wedding but will reopen for regular hours Tuesday 7/6. 🇺🇸


Happy high school graduation weekend Iowa City! We have the treats, cards, gifts, and supplies you need for your favorite grad! 🎓🥳

Photos from Shelter House - Iowa City's post 05/07/2021

Today until 2pm! Check it out and bid on a dessert by placing your bid in the comments of the item you want! 100% of sales go to Shelter House - Iowa City


Ticket sales end soon! Decorate a cake with me today at 2pm and help raise money for Box of Balloons, Inc.- Iowa City, IA

Only 2 Hrs till our sweet cake decorating contest, will we see you there?


🦄It’s National Unicorn Day!🦄

This fun cake was originally ordered at the beginning of the pandemic but was paused until the party could be rescheduled. A year later, the birthday girl got her unicorn cake and the order was updated to include her current interest in mermaids! 🦄🧜🏼‍♀️🐚

Photos from Butter Custom Bakery, LLC's post 03/31/2021

We have everything you need for Easter including a limited number of prefilled baskets! Stop in Thursday & Friday 8am-2pm or Saturday 10am-2pm

Photos from Butter Custom Bakery, LLC's post 03/30/2021

There’s still time to order Easter goodies! Hop over to our website to place an order!


Stop in tomorrow, March 27th, from 10am-2pm and check out the new retail items we have to offer! Party supplies, greeting cards, gifts, and candy! We have everything you need to fill an Easter basket. Plus, save 10% on any retail items purchased in the shop or online tomorrow!

Photos from Butter Custom Bakery, LLC's post 02/13/2021

Still need gifts or treats for Valentine’s Day? Stop by the bakery today until 3 or come check out the pop up shops at in West Branch until 5! ❤️💕❤️💕


There’s still time to order hot cocoa bombs and cookie decorating kits for a fun activity after sledding or a new NYE tradition!

Head over to our website to see what flavors we offer and to place an order!




Our holiday hot cocoa bombs are now available! ☕️🍫🎄❄️

Choose from: dark chocolate, milk chocolate, vanilla, candy cane, eggnog, gingerbread, s’mores, cookies & cream, reindeer, and unicorn!

Head over to buttercustombakery.com to place your order today!


Our Thanksgiving Hot Cocoa Bombs come in a 4 pack with one white chocolate bomb, one salted caramel bomb, one milk chocolate acorn or squirrel, and one dark chocolate owl.

Just place in a mug and pour hot milk over the bomb then watch it melt into the best hot cocoa you’ve ever had!

Photos from Butter Custom Bakery, LLC's post 11/17/2020

Let us help you with dessert this Thanksgiving! Curbside pickup available.


Help us spread the word and thank our Veterans tomorrow with a free cookie and coffee!


I was going to caption this with a mummy joke, but I think I’ll keep it under wraps.

We have all the spooky treats you need! Call, email, or stop in Tuesday - Saturday 8am - 2pm 🎃🕸👻


The bakery will be closed today (10/17) and tomorrow (10/18) but will reopen Tuesday at 8am with new hours and new menu items!!

Timeline photos 07/26/2020

Turtle brownies in the case today and they are turtley awesome! 🐢


Today until 4pm come get a free sprinkle filled cupcake with any purchase of $10 or more! Carry out or curbside pick up. 🎉

Timeline photos 07/24/2020

Cookie order today to celebrate Opening Day!! ⚾️🎉🍪

Timeline photos 07/03/2020

See you all next week!

Timeline photos 06/26/2020

We will have croissants in the case this weekend until they are gone! Our front will be open for carry-out Saturday and Sunday 9am-2pm! 🥐💛🥐


Stop in this weekend from 8-2! We are excited to see all of our regular customers again and some new faces. We will have caramel pecan rolls, orange rolls, cinnamon rolls, muffins, cake donuts, cookies, cupcakes, bars and more!



Timeline photos 04/09/2020

Cookie decorating kits make a fun addition to an Easter basket or a special weekend activity!

Photos from Butter Custom Bakery, LLC's post 04/08/2020

To enter, like this post and add a gif in the comments that describes how you've been spending your days in quarantine!

I will randomly choose 2 winners Friday 4/10 for their choice of Easter cake for pickup on Saturday 4/11

Check out our Easter menu and order by Friday for Saturday curb side pickup!

Timeline photos 04/04/2020

We wanted to take a moment to say, “thank you!” We have faced a lot of uncertainty the last few weeks and this community’s efforts to support small businesses in the area has been very reassuring!
It is heartwarming to see so many people using our cookies and cupcakes as a way to connect with neighbors, friends, and family as well as a way to thank health care workers!
We are still offering curbside pickup and non contact delivery so please reach out if you would like to place an order or if there is anything at all we can do for you.
Keep an eye out tomorrow for our Easter menu, ordering info, and a giveaway!
[email protected] or (319)519-6335

Timeline photos 03/17/2020

Looking for a fun activity to keep kids or yourself busy? Starting tomorrow 3/18 we will have edible slime and cookie decorating kits! Order by calling (319)519-6335 or email [email protected]

Timeline photos 03/17/2020

In keeping with Gov. Reynolds’ mandate and CDC recommendations, our doors will be closed to the public until further notice. However, we are happy to offer car-side and home delivery.

Timeline photos 03/07/2020

All set for a unicorn cookie decorating party! 🦄🍪🥳

Timeline photos 03/01/2020

The only thing this beautiful Sunday needs is a roll fresh from the oven! We have orange, caramel pecan, and cinnamon while they last!

Timeline photos 02/12/2020



Head over to Bur Oak Land Trust’s page to learn about the awesome work they are doing, help them reach their fundraising goal AND like their post from Monday to enter to win cookies made by us!

Timeline photos 02/01/2020

Mother of all markets is right now! Book a party or order a cake at the market today and receive 10% off of your order!

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Iowa City?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)




805 S 1st Avenue
Iowa City, IA

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 2pm
Wednesday 8am - 2pm
Thursday 8am - 2pm
Friday 8am - 2pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Other Bakeries in Iowa City (show all)
Brownie Encino Brownie Encino
243 South Clinton Street
Iowa City, 52240

I've given you my Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookies, so it was time to move on to brownies. My perfect

The Wedge Pizzeria The Wedge Pizzeria
521 IA-1
Iowa City, 52246

iCake iCake
Iowa City, 52246

iCake was founded on the philosophy of donating to those who risk their lives on the front lines fig

Elida's Bakery Elida's Bakery
2128 S. Riverside Drive #99
Iowa City, 52246

Elida's Bakery LLC (Licensed In-Home Bakery) Custom Cakes, Cupcakes and More! Se Habla Español

LolliCakes LolliCakes
Iowa Avenue
Iowa City, 52240

Custom cake pops made to order. Sold by the dozen.

V&K Sweets and Creations V&K Sweets and Creations
Iowa City, 52240

We're a Home Bakery licensed. We make variety of desserts. Also do personalized items.

Kooker's Kookies Kooker's Kookies
Iowa City

Creating delicious custom decorated sugar cookies from my home to yours! Cookies for all occasions!

Sweet Joy Baking Iowa City Sweet Joy Baking Iowa City
Iowa City, 52245

Welcome to Sweet Joy! I’m excited to share in the joys of sweets. Please contact me to order! ��

Deluxe Cakes & Pastries Deluxe Cakes & Pastries
812 S Summit Street
Iowa City, 52240

Deluxe Cakes and Pastries is a from-scratch neighborhood bakery located in Iowa City. http://www.y

Molly's Cupcakes Iowa City Molly's Cupcakes Iowa City
14 South Clinton Street
Iowa City, 52240

Fun bakery located in the heart of down town Iowa City offering cookies, bars, cheesecakes, ice cream

The Mad Batter The Mad Batter
Iowa City, 50021

I am just starting my new at-home baking business. I am pursuing my life-long passion and hope I ca

Confections of a Cheesecake Confections of a Cheesecake
Iowa City, 52240

Creating cheesecake masterpieces. Message me for a list of flavors!