J3 Custom Cookies

These sweet cookie-and-coffee gift sets are the easiest way to spread a little Christmas joy! Perfect for teachers, coaches, admin staff—anyone you want to surprise with a festive treat this season.

Each set is just $10 and includes a $5 Starbucks gift card, and I’m happy to upgrade to a larger gift card if you’d like. And if you missed out on the infamous bear cup… this cookie is a delicious stand-in!

Message me to grab yours before they’re gone!

What is this weekend?....

We have a few cookie spots available before orders close for this weekend at 10am tomorrow.

Ready for the big Christmas Eve debate… are we putting the kids down at 6? 7? Whatever time you choose, level up the whole aura of the night with our Gingerbread and Santa 67 cookies. They’re sweet, a little skibiddy, and absolutely perfect for stuffing those stockings. Pre-orders open now for pick up December 18-23 at J3 Custom Cookies!

It’s the sweetest time of the year, and we’re kicking things off in a big way.
Christmas pre-orders open November 23, and we’re starting with our most-loved holiday classic: Cookie Ornaments.

These sell out fast every year, and we’ll have a more limited supply this season, so early orders are your best friend.

And that’s just the beginning. Each day after, we’ll reveal a new holiday preorder item, including:

• A brand-new, on-trend Santa
• A charming Gingerbread Cookie
• Our Cookie Exchange Box – all the festive flavors you love without lifting a finger
• And the return of Joe’s Good Neighbor Box, always a holiday hit

Set your reminders, tell your cookie-loving friends, and get ready to snag your favorites before they’re gone.

Holiday cookie magic starts November 23. Let’s bake up some cheer.

Big game tonight? Gender reveal coming up? When you need cookies ready no matter the outcome, IF THEN Cookies are the way to go!

These cookie sets include two dozen 3" square cookies—one for each possibility. For tonight’s volleyball championship, our “Champions” cookie comes decked out with a gold bow and trophy. But win or lose, the team will have a sweet treat waiting, thanks to the “just as special” second option.

25% off the second dozen with our IF THEN Cookie Special
*terms and conditions apply

Let’s make your celebration perfect—message us to get started!

And spoiler alert - the Panthers played their hearts out and took second in the tournament!!!

Today, we’re thinking of Ms. B, who is heading into surgery for a liver transplant. She wanted to thank the incredible medical team performing the procedure in the sweetest, most personal way—with custom cookies shaped like a liver.

We're honored to be part of such a meaningful moment and ask our J3 community to join us in sending positive thoughts, strength, and well wishes her way today.

No cookie cutter themes here!

From a unicorn pool party for Calla’s 8th birthday to a backyard carnival or a llama adoption celebration (yes, that’s a thing—we’re ready!), J3 Custom Cookies loves turning the wild and whimsical into edible art.

Challenge us! Drop your most creative, unusual, or oddly specific party theme in the comments… we dare you! Let’s see who can stump the cookie cutter. 👇

When the team is craving popsicles but the gym says absolutely not… we’ve got a game-winning backup plan!

Introducing our Cherry Popsicle Cookies on a Stick – all the fun, none of the mess, and 100% playoff-approved. Perfect for sweet celebrations, sideline snacks, or just a treat after a hard-fought match.

Good luck in the playoffs, girls – go get that W!
(And yes, we’re cheering and cookie-ing from the sidelines.)

Need a custom cookie solution for your next event? Let’s make it delicious!

No theme? No problem! Whether you're toasting with champagne or diving into your love of sardines and clams, we've got you covered!

These custom bridal shower cookies were anything but basic—complete with shimmering pearls and a whole lot of sparkle to celebrate the bride-to-be. Sweet, sassy, and seriously unique—just like the bride herself!

Planning a party with a personality all its own? Let J3 Custom Cookies bring your vision (or vibe!) to life—no matter how quirky, classy, or clam-tastic it may be.

Congratulations to the bride-to-be—we hope you loved every bite!

Just made the sweetest little housewarming gift! These custom cookies were a thoughtful treat from a realtor to her newly married clients celebrating their new home, new chapter, and all the adventures ahead.

New keys, new last name, and a lifetime of memories to come—life is just going to keep getting sweeter!

Special fundraiser to support Jessica's mission trip. Get your order today!!

https://cookie-fundraiser.square.site/

Game, Set, SWEET!

These vibrant volleyball cookies are more than just a snack—they're a slam dunk (okay, a killer spike) for any team celebration!

Whether you're looking for a post-game pick-me-up or a standout treat for your end-of-season banquet, custom cookies are the MVP of memorable moments. Let us design the perfect cookie for your team—school colors, jersey numbers, logos, you name it.

Because every player deserves something sweet!

Message us today to get your team on our calendar—your custom cookie game just went pro.