Cute as a Button Cookies

Cute as a Button Cookies


Hi, this is Katie coming to you from my newly set up personal page. I still don't have login access to this account. Please follow me on Instagram!
I loved being back at my alma mater showing prospective students everything the @parktudor community has to offer!

Planning + Production @annerogersproductions
Tent + Rentals Mutton Party & Tent Rental
Audio-Visual NBE Event Group
Plants McNamara Florist
Balloons Banzi Balloons + Event Services
Cookies Cute as a Button Cookies
Drink Service Quest Beverages
We had the best time helping Tess + Ryan plan their wedding for over a year! Thank you Unique Heart Productions for capturing it so beautifully! Thanks to our entire fabulous team: Something Blue Stylists, Accent Floral Design LLC, Kahn's Catering, Eiteljorg Museum of American Indians and Western Art, Indiana Statehouse, Lakeside Entertainment, and Cute as a BuCute as a Button Cookies
Hi Katie! My son is graduating from high school this year. We are doing a combined grad party with two of his friends on June 3rd. I would like to talk to you about some ideas for cookies. Let me know the best way to contact you to discuss! Thanks!!
Hi Katie sent a message about a possible cookie order wanted to make sure you got it!
Thank you so much Cute as a Button. That cookies were a big hit !
Hi Katie. I sent you a PM message about my order for September 21. Let me know if you have any questions! Your cookies continue to amaze me!!!

Custom cookies by Katie Maurer My name is Katie Maurer and I make specialty cookies for any and every occasion ... birthdays, graduations, housewarming, corporate events, holidays, bar mitzvahs, baptisms, sporting events, celebrations and much more.

My sugar cookies are homemade with fresh ingredients (butter, sugar, salt, baking powder, egg, flour and vanilla). Please contact me if you have any questions about nutritional information or allergies. As of now, I do not offer any vegan, dairy- or gluten-free varieties. Pricing

Boxed cookies: $42 per dozen
(If a cookie is small, I will include extra so your order is equivalent to one dozen)


Operating as usual


Easter orders are still open!
Pick up is Friday April 15.

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 03/22/2022

Shop here for Easter cookies! πŸ°πŸ£πŸ’—

Cute as a Button Cookies added a Shop on Website button to their Page. 03/22/2022

Cute as a Button Cookies added a Shop on Website button to their Page.

Cute as a Button Cookies added a Shop on Website button to their Page.


I can’t believe it, but I am finally back into my page! I have missed connecting with you all over the past 2 months! πŸ’—


Omg I think I got back in!!


Ready or not, Valentines Day is coming up! I am currently designing and prepping my samples. Ordering will most likely open early next week and pickups will be Friday February 11.

I will be trying some new packaging ideas this year and bringing back some of my most popular designs, including my favorite frog! (Top left corner of photo. Cutter by @thesweetdesignsshoppe)

Stay tuned! β€οΈπŸ’ŒπŸ’˜

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 01/10/2022

No one does sports like Indy! And no one does logo cookies like @notenoughdoughcookies. Thank you to my friend Kay and cookie collaborator on this massive order for tonight’s @cfbplayoff. 2,800 cookies for the suites at @lucasoil.stadium!

Turning around this kind of order right after the holidays and a season of Colts cookies was not easy. And it would have been impossible without Kay. ❀️

I love my hometown. Indy has a vibrant sports scene and an amazing cookie community … I admire all of my cookie friends and wish you all a 2022 filled with great business opportunities. But don’t forget to maintain a little balance. I know so many of my cookie friends are moms with kids of all ages and it is not easy to do what we do.

Good luck to @alabamafbl and @georgiafootball. 🏈🏈🏈


Thank you @stelmosteakhouse and @univofalabama. Good luck to the @alabamafbl in tonight’s game! 🏈🐘❀️


Nutcracker feels like a million years ago πŸ­πŸŽ„πŸ’•

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 12/02/2021

Last call! I will be closing orders soon. THANK YOU!!

Now taking Christmas orders! Here is the link!


I love this photo of all the cookies jumbled up together. Similar to my state of mind right now! πŸ€ͺπŸ€ͺπŸ€ͺ

TOMORROW is the day for Christmas cookie sales! Please check back here for the link at 12 noon.

As of now, there will be two pickup days … Wednesday December 15 and Wednesday December 22. I always struggle with choosing the best days. I think these two dates allow for teacher gifts, holiday parties and Christmas Eve/Day. All cookies will be individually sealed for freshness.

Thank you and happy December 1st! β€οΈπŸŽ„πŸŽ…πŸ»


Happy Thanksgiving πŸ§‘πŸ’›πŸ’š


Last call for Thanksgiving cookies! Thank you to everyone who has ordered 🧑


Hanukkah is early this year! November 28-December 6 to be exact. (We almost had another Thanksgivikkah on our hands. πŸ˜… πŸ¦ƒ πŸ•Ž)

I am working on my Hanukkah samples today and hope to have those available on my site tomorrow. Pick ups will most likely be Saturday November 27. All cookies will be individually bagged for freshness throughout the eight festive nights!

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 11/14/2021

Thanksgiving sales are open!
Pickup will be Tuesday November 23. Thank you!


Thanksgiving cookies will go on sale tomorrow at 1 pm! πŸ¦ƒ 🍁 πŸ₯§

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 11/08/2021

Almost time to get β€œcracking”! Can’t wait for Nutcracker season! 🩰 πŸ’ƒπŸΌπŸ­β„οΈπŸ­πŸŽ„


O-H-I-O! 🏈❀️


She found her main squeeze πŸ’›πŸ‹


Booked for custom orders in 2021 but still offering lots of holiday options!

Cute as a Button Cookies updated their info in the about section. 10/14/2021

Cute as a Button Cookies updated their info in the about section.

Cute as a Button Cookies updated their info in the about section.


SOLD! Thank you and Go Hoosiers!

FLASH SALE! Hoosier fans headed down to Bloomington for IU homecoming! I have 3 dozen IU football cookies available for pickup Friday in West Carmel. $42 per dozen, can be individually bagged for 25 cents extra per cookie. Please comment below if interested.

Cute as a Button Cookies 10/10/2021

Cute as a Button Cookies

Shop for Halloween cookies here! πŸŽƒ

Pick up: West Carmel Wednesday October 27-Saturday October 30.

Cute as a Button Cookies Custom decorated cookie business serving Central Indiana

Cute as a Button Cookies 10/10/2021

Cute as a Button Cookies

Shop now for Halloween cookies!

Pick up: West Carmel Wednesday October 27-Saturday October 30. Pick up address will be provided when you receive order confirmation.

I hope to add Thanksgiving options next week. Thank you and Happy Halloween!

Cute as a Button Cookies Custom decorated cookie business serving Central Indiana

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 10/09/2021

Halloween sales will begin tomorrow at 4 pm!


Retirement cookies for a longtime @stelmosteakhouse employee. I’ve been making versions of this set for several years and I always love how they turn out. And the shrimp? If you know, you know! πŸ₯©πŸ¦πŸ€΅β€β™‚️

Photos from Cute as a Button Cookies's post 10/02/2021

Lots of babies on the way! It’s almost like something has been keeping people indoors a lot πŸ€”


I love fall most of all 🧑

But fall is a BUSY time! Looking at my family and cookie calendar, I have made the difficult decision that I cannot accept any more custom orders for the remainder of 2021. This will give me the time to focus on Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas cookie projects.

I look forward to sharing designs for the upcoming season. Halloween cookies will be available for pre sale soon!

Thank you for your continued support! xx Katie


Posting twice today because I’m so happy it’s football season!! 🏈❀️


Purdue fans ... keep scrolling


BOXED COOKIES: $36 per dozen
(If a cookie is small, I will include extra so your order is equivalent to one dozen)

LARGE COOKIES (more than 5") or elaborate detail: $1 extra per cookie. Detailed character cookies and certain logos fall into this category.

FAVORS (with cellophane bag and ribbon): Start at $3.50 per favor. $3.25 for cookies in heat-sealed bags.


PICK-UP/DELIVERY: I do not have regular pick-up hours. When your order is confirmed we can discuss the best time for you to pick up from my home in West Carmel. Delivery is sometimes available; again, this can be discussed when the order is placed.

Videos (show all)

Ta-da! That moment when you lift a stencil off a cookie and pray. πŸ™Airbrushing not my favorite technique but it makes so...
A real-time video of filling in letters. This process is time consuming when there are a lot of names involved, but I lo...
I’m completely terrible at making videos πŸ€¦πŸΌβ€β™€οΈ but I thought it would be fun to share a little detail for these Viking h...
My Friday night. It's surprisingly difficult not to laugh when your daughter is taking a video of you making disco ball ...
Emojis in the making ... all my videographers are at summer camp so I'm filming with my left hand and icing with my righ...
A custom sprinkle mix quickly transforms freshly iced cookies. I love the festive look!
Back to work! πŸ’›
Airbrushing a subtle shimmery brick pattern on these cookies tonight. Can anyone guess what they're for?



Custom decorated sugar cookies



2422 Burnham Walk
Carmel, IN

Other Bakeries in Carmel (show all)
Classic Cakes Classic Cakes
1752 E 116th St
Carmel, 46032

A custom cake shop creating unique cakes for unique people. Orders, walk-in ready cakes, cupcake club, online tutorials & classes. We serve everyone. οΏ½ Owned by Megan Ritz @meganmalloryritz

A Dog Bakery A Dog Bakery
816 W Main St
Carmel, 46032

"A Dog Bakery"... Specializing in Gourmet Dog Treats baked in-house, Holistic Select, Solid Gold and Fromm Dog & Cat Food and Pet Supplies.

Sweet Bites Bakery Sweet Bites Bakery

Sweet Bites Bakery is a local small business in Central Indiana. We take pride in our baked goods, we only use the highest quality ingredients to ensure you get the best tasting item!!! We look forward to creating the best for you!!

Uptown Cafe Carmel Uptown Cafe Carmel
Carmel, 46032-3282

Locally owned and operated. Takes pride in serving fresh, homemade items served hot directly from kitchen to the table. Bake all our breads and pastry’s in house, adding a more personalized touch to our menu. We are excited to have you!

Kolache Factory Kolache Factory
10460 North Michigan Road
Carmel, 46032

Kolache Factory is committed to authenticity, craftsmanship and food innovation by serving the freshest kolaches and specialty products.

Katie's Creations Katie's Creations
Carmel, 46032

Custom cakes and cupcakes

Panera Bread Panera Bread
2001 East Greyhound Pass, Suite 4E
Carmel, 46033

kj's bakery kj's bakery
Carmel, 46032

Bakery and sweet treats

Faith's Cake Ball Factory Faith's Cake Ball Factory
930 N Rangeline Rd
Carmel, 46032

HELEN coffee shop HELEN coffee shop
201 W Main St, Suit 100
Carmel, 46032

Please call to place your order 317-603-9772 (we require minimum 48 hours for cakes)

Designs by ME Designs by ME
10508 White Oak Dr
Carmel, 46033

Artistic Services ranging from: Interior Design Consultantion and Creative Planning/Custom Cakes/Event Planner/ Custom Artwork and Murals

With Sugar on Top With Sugar on Top
Carmel, 46074

Delicious and customized cakes, cupcakes, cake pops and cookies for special occasion! Just private message me anytime!