Restaurants in Bay Shore, NY - Page 1

Find restaurants in Bay Shore, NY. Listings include Coyle's Ice Cream, The LakeHouse, Nicky's on the Bay, fatfish on the Water, Captain Bills Restaurant and Catering, Verde Kitchen & Cocktails.

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Bay Shore, NY?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Coyle's Ice Cream A Coyle's Ice Cream
75 Howells Road
Bay Shore, 11706

The best homemade ice cream and cakes since 1985! Sit in one of our booths or at our soda fountain -

The LakeHouse B The LakeHouse
Bay Shore

Nicky's on the Bay C Nicky's on the Bay
150 S Clinton Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Nicky’s on the Bay — a top-rated waterfront restaurant in Bay Shore, NY, known for fresh

fatfish on the Water D fatfish on the Water
28 Cottage Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

REOPENING APRIL 2025! Overlooking Long Island's gorgeous Great South Bay, fatfish is a lively Mediterranean-inspired seafood destination.

Captain Bills Restaurant and Catering E Captain Bills Restaurant and Catering
122 Ocean Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

Seafood & steak specialist in a charming waterfront building with a full bar & Sunday brunch.

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails F Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
70 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Creative Mexican, craft cocktails, additive free agave selection, catering & events, Sunday brunch

Aji 53 G Aji 53
53 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Aji 53 is a Japanese fusion restaurant with stylish decor, personal service and a warm atmosphere.

Tula Kitchen H Tula Kitchen
41 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Live to Eat - Eat to Live

Goody Two Shoes I Goody Two Shoes
42 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Casual restaurant dishing up burgers, short ribs, and other comfort food plus a good beer selection.

Salt & Barrel J Salt & Barrel
61 W Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe & vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps & coastal fare with a rotating selection of oysters daily

Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar K Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar
12 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

One of Long Islands best Cocktail Bars featuring coastal inspired food and travel inspired cocktails

Whalers Restaurant & Bar L Whalers Restaurant & Bar
124 Maple Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

Now open year round! Join us at Whalers in Bay Shore and enjoy some amazing food, drinks and music w

Tullulahs M Tullulahs
12 4th Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

If you do what you love, life will find a way to take care of you.

Eat Me,Drink Me Truck N Eat Me,Drink Me Truck
Food Truck
Bay Shore, 11706

A Gourmet food truck serving grass fed beef, hand cut fries, artisanal grilled cheese and local organic produce throughout Long Island.

Local Burger - Bay Shore O Local Burger - Bay Shore
62 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

World famous juicy hand-pressed burgers, homemade sides, wings, bbq, craft beer, cocktails, wine + vegetarian & gluten-free menu, a kid's menu & more! *Monday: 2 for 1 MilkShakes

Changing Times Bay Shore P Changing Times Bay Shore
29 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Features gastropub dining, quality craft & local beer selections, food & drink specials for all sporting events, wall-to-wall HDTVs, outdoor bar & patio.

Que Rica Comida Q Que Rica Comida
140 Pine Aire Drive
Bay Shore, 11706

Welcome to Que Rica Comida! We specialize in delicious cuisine, including our house specialties and other customer favorites.

Kitty Mulligan's R Kitty Mulligan's
615 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Irish Pub with Live Music

Zestlongisland S Zestlongisland
Bay Shore

Chef Mike Liebman, brings explosive flavors to Bayshore, Long Island! Great Food, Local Beer

BELLA VIE T BELLA VIE
240 West Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Fine dining italian restaurant with waterfront views in the heart of Bay Shore.

Fire Island Vines U Fire Island Vines
17 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

We are a family-owned business. Our winery tasting room offers a Fire Island Beach House décor. Our FIV labeled wines are produced locally. Our menu is Greek inspired because our f...

Pico Tequila Grill V Pico Tequila Grill
19 W Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Pico Tequila Grill is a true authentic Mexican restaurant and Tequila bar. Stop by for yourself and see why Long Island loves us so much.

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails W The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
150 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Bar Lucy is your neighborhood, sexy Italian joint…

Fratelli Pizzeria X Fratelli Pizzeria
553 East Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Fratelli Ristorante and Pizzeria of Bay Shore Fan Page!

El Apretador Bay Shore Y El Apretador Bay Shore
1531 Brentwood Road
Bay Shore, 11706

Tap Room Z Tap Room
44 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

At Tap Room Bay Shore, located at 44-46 E Main St, enjoy a great dining experience with family and f

Bay Shore Bean Coffee House 1 Bay Shore Bean Coffee House
47 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Bay Shore Bean Coffee House

The Penny Pub 2 The Penny Pub
79 W Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Long-standing neighborhood watering hole offering pub fare, drinks, live entertainment, and karaoke.

Golden chicken Peruvian cuisine 3 Golden chicken Peruvian cuisine
164 E Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Abierto de 11.30am to 10pm lunes a domingo Open to 11.30am to 10pm monday to sunday

Valentinos Pizza-Peruvian Restaurant 4 Valentinos Pizza-Peruvian Restaurant
1597 Manatuck Boulevard
Bay Shore, 11706

Restaurant Peruano&Pizza https://linktr.ee/valentinosperuvianrestaurant

Pecado Mexican 5 Pecado Mexican
49 W Main Street
Bay Shore, 11706

Located in the heart of Bay Shore, Pecado Mexican offers authentic, modern Mexican cuisine in a vibr

Pollo Campero 6 Pollo Campero
1665 Fifth Avenue
Bay Shore, 11706

Serving flavorful chicken since 1971

KPot Hot Pot & KBBQ -Bayshore NY 7 KPot Hot Pot & KBBQ -Bayshore NY
1701 Sunrise Highway, STE A1
Bay Shore, 11706

All you can eat hot pot & kbbq

Honey & Sweet by Sonia 8 Honey & Sweet by Sonia
Bay Shore

Somos una empresa dedicada a la elaboración de postres, dulces, tortas personalizadas, bocaditos de sal y de dulce con productos de muy alta calidad.